The short version
To process an online return in Shopify, approve the customer's request with Review request, or create the return yourself on the order, then pick one of three return shipping options.
When the items are back and inspected, click Process return, select Restock at for anything going back on sale, and refund now or later.
Refund to the original payment, to store credit, or to both, and check the Refund amount against your fees before you confirm.
Create the return before any refund: Shopify won't let you create one after a refund, a refund can't be reversed, and a Shopify return label, available only for domestic US or Canadian returns, can't be voided.
When a customer wants to send something back, Shopify turns it into a return on the order. In the words of Shopify's returns overview, you can create a return, send shipping instructions, and issue refunds after inspecting the returned items. The steps are spread across Shopify's returns, return label, refunding and store credit pages; this guide puts them in the order you meet them, for online orders.
Three moments in that run can't be taken back: a refund, a Shopify return label, and refunding before the return exists. All of them are on one screen in What you can't undo. Shopify's Help Center and changelog were read for this guide on November 14, 2026.
Request or Email: Where an Online Return Starts
Key takeaway
Every return lives on the order it belongs to, whichever way it started. What changes is your first move, so start from what you actually have in front of you:
Where your return starts
| What you have | Where it shows | Your first move |
|---|---|---|
| A return request the customer submitted | An email to you if you receive order notifications by email, the Customer request filter on your Orders page, and a Return requested section on the order | Review the request, then approve or decline it |
| A customer email or chat message asking to send items back | Your inbox or chat | Create the return yourself on the order; it works only for fulfilled items that haven't been refunded |
| A cancellation request for items not yet fulfilled | The Customer request filter on your Orders page | Not a return, and it doesn't cancel the order on its own: remove the items through the refund flow, or decline the request or mark it as resolved |
| A fulfilled order whose payment was never collected | The order's payment status | Don't cancel it: Shopify's canceling orders page says canceling prevents you from collecting payment, and to use the returns process to get items back |
Source: Shopify Help Center pages on self-serve requests, creating returns and canceling orders, read November 14, 2026.
- Orders
Not everyone on your staff can act on a request. Reviewing one takes the store owner or a staff member with the Orders permission. Creating a return by hand needs the Return permission, and refunding it needs Refund to original payment or Refund to store credit, depending on the refund method.
What Has to Be On Before Customers Can Ask
Key takeaway
This guide starts where the request arrives, so it covers the settings only as far as they change what you'll see. Which request types to allow, how wide to open the windows and the EU rules are in our guide to what self-serve returns switch on, and where.
Three points from Shopify's self-serve setup page decide what reaches your admin:
- Requests don't come from legacy customer accounts. Customers submit requests in the new version of customer accounts, and can also submit return requests in the Shop app when the order's email matches their verified Shop app account; legacy customer accounts don't show return or cancellation options. If you use them, add the customer accounts URL to your store's footer, refund policy or another page, and it takes customers to the new version, where they can.
- B2B orders are included. Self-serve returns and cancellations work with all orders, including B2B orders, and can't be turned on for some order types only.
- A return request holds at most 250 line items. Customers can't submit a return request with more than that; above it, they submit separate requests.
Return rules keep working even if self-serve is never switched on, and Shopify's return rules page is explicit about it:
Even if self-serve returns and cancellations are deactivated, return rules still apply when you process returns manually.
Changes to those rules apply only to future orders, so an order placed before your edit keeps the rules it was sold under. Our answer on whether return rule changes apply to existing orders goes through it.
As of November 14, 2026, Shopify's pages differ on per-market control, so check your own Customer accounts settings: the setup page still ties it to the Advanced or Plus plan and calls the checkout and accounts editor early access, while a changelog post of November 10, 2026 says “You can now tailor that experience to each market you operate in.”
How Do You Approve or Decline a Return Request?
Key takeaway
The pages we read on November 14, 2026 don't give a deadline after which a request closes, declines or approves by itself (see “What we looked for and did not find” below).
Those pages also describe no built-in automatic approval. Shopify Flow does have a Return requested trigger that starts a workflow when a customer requests a return through self-serve returns, and our answer on whether Shopify can approve return requests automatically covers the routes that exist.
Approve: Exchange Items and the Way Back
Key takeaway
- From Orders, open the order with the request.
- In the Return requested section, click Review request.
- Optional: edit the restocking fee or return shipping fee, and add exchange items.
- Under Return shipping options, choose how the customer sends the items back.
- Click Approve.
- Orders
- Order details
- Orders
- Order details
- Review request
In the Shopify mobile app, tap Return requested and then Approve.
The approval form is where exchange items enter a self-serve return. Shopify's setup page says exchanges can't be requested in self-serve returns, and there are no exchange-specific return rules, so when a customer wants a different item, the exchange is yours to add. Our returns-apps guide looks at whether customers can request an exchange themselves once an app is involved.
After you approve, Shopify sends the customer a confirmation email, and the return label too if you created or uploaded one. Refunding and restocking stay with you until the items are back and inspected.
Decline: The Reason Stays Internal, the Message Doesn't
Key takeaway
Declining asks for a Decline reason and a Message to customer, and only one of them leaves your store:
A decline reason isn't displayed to your customer and is for internal use only.
The message is filled from a template that matches the reason, so edit it wherever your situation differs. When you click Decline request, the customer receives an email with that message.
- Orders
- Order details
- Review request
When the Customer Emailed: Create the Return Yourself
Key takeaway
A return you create by hand runs through the same steps as one a customer requested; nothing appears on the order until you start it. Shopify's creating returns page sets the order of operations in one sentence:
If a customer is sending items back, then create the return before you refund the items.
The order matters for two reasons. Shopify's refunding page says you can refund an order without creating a return, but you can't create a return after a refund has been issued. And the text in Reason for refund is a note for you and your staff, not a return reason, so a refund without a return leaves nothing for reports that read return reasons, such as Top returned products with reasons.
- From Orders, open the order.
- Click Return. If the order still has unfulfilled items, click More actions > Return instead.
- Under Select quantity to return, enter how many of each item are coming back.
- Choose a Return reason for each item.
- Optional: edit the restocking fee or return shipping fee in the Summary, and add exchange items with Add products.
- Under Return shipping options, choose one of the three options in the next section.
- Click Create return.
In the Shopify mobile app, tap the menu icon and then Return.
- Orders
- Order details
- Return
Which Return Shipping Option Should You Pick?
Key takeaway
Return shipping options appear both when you approve a request and when you create a return, and the choice decides how the parcel travels and what you pay:
Return shipping options
| Option | Pick it when | What to know first |
|---|---|---|
| Create a return label in Shopify | Your location and the customer's shipping address are in the same country, and that country is the US or Canada | Billed pay-on-scan to your Shopify account; it can't be voided, but it can expire |
| Upload a return label | You bought the label from a carrier or a shipping app, such as for an international return | Upload a PDF, PNG or JPEG file or a URL, and add the tracking number and shipping carrier |
| No shipping required | The return needs no shipping information from you, for example when your return rules have customers buy their own label | The return is created without any return shipping information |
Source: Shopify Help Center pages on creating returns and return labels, read November 14, 2026.
Check which option is selected before you click Create return or Approve, and switch to Upload a return label or No shipping required if you don't need a label from Shopify; our test shows what each form had selected. With No shipping required, the form warns: “A notification is not sent when no return shipping is required.”
- Orders
- Order details
- Return
A Shopify return label is domestic-only. The return labels page says they're available only for domestic orders within the United States or within Canada, so not between the two, and not for US military addresses (APO/FPO/DPO), US territories that require a customs form, or international addresses.
Which carriers and services a Shopify return label can use comes with its own phone and signature conditions, and our answer on which carriers you can use for a Shopify return label lists them.
A Shopify return label is billed pay-on-scan to your Shopify account, and if the returned package weighs more than the estimated weight you entered, the charge is higher. Labels are created at the order level, not the item level, so adjust the weight when only part of an order comes back. They also expire: USPS labels 1 year after they're created, UPS labels after 6 months and FedEx labels after 90 days, while Canada Post labels don't expire.
If a return already exists without a label and the customer now needs one, that case has its own steps: see what Return label not sent means in Shopify.
Who pays for the trip back is set in your return rules: free return shipping, a flat rate charged one time per return, or customers buying their own label.
Return Fees: Where Shopify's Two Help Pages Disagree
Key takeaway
Fees show up while you approve or create the return. A restocking fee can be edited by return or by item, but a return shipping fee only by return; both are displayed based on your return rules, and you can edit them for a specific return.
What happens to those fees at refund time is where Shopify's pages part ways:
Two Help Center pages on return fees
| Help Center page | What it says about fees at refund time |
|---|---|
| Setting up return and cancellation rules | “Return fees aren't automatically deducted from refunds.” |
| Processing and managing returns | “When you process a return, the restocking fee is calculated by how many items you choose to process in a return. The return shipping fee is applied the first time you process the return.” |
Source: Shopify Help Center, Setting up return and cancellation rules and Processing and managing returns, both read November 14, 2026.
Shopify's processing page says Process return calculates the fees and that the amount you owe is added to the Refund amount when you refund later, while the return rules page says fees aren't deducted automatically when you create a refund. So process the return before you refund, deduct the fees yourself if you refund from the order before the return is processed, and check the Refund amount on any screen before you confirm. Our test of these screens is in the next section.
Return shipping fees can also carry tax now. Starting October 23, 2026, if an order was shipped to an address in the United States and you use Shopify Tax or Tax Platform, tax is calculated on its return shipping fees where the fee is taxable in that jurisdiction. Restocking fees aren't taxed, and return shipping fees stay untaxed on tax-exempt orders or if you use another tax service, such as Manual Tax or Basic Tax.
What Our Development Store Showed About Return Fees and Screen Defaults
Key takeaway
We ran this on November 14, 2026, on our Shopify development store with a test payment gateway, not Shopify Payments: a manual return on a fulfilled order with one $5.00 item, a 20% restocking fee and a $0.50 return shipping fee, with No shipping required. A second order the same day, marked as paid by hand, started as a customer's return request: we approved it with No shipping required, set a return shipping fee and a 20% restocking fee by hand on the return, processed it with Later without restocking, and opened the order's Refund screen without issuing a refund.
What each screen showed, November 14, 2026
| What we did | What the screen showed | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Created the return (Summary on the Return and exchange page) | Return item −$5.00, return shipping fee $0.50, restocking fee $1.00, Expected refund $3.50 | Fees you set on the return show as deductions before you create it |
| Opened Create return (first order) and Review request (second order) | On our first order's Create return form, Create a return label in Shopify was preselected; on a second order's Review return request form, that option was unavailable, with a note that return labels need the return location and the customer's shipping address both set and in the same country, and Upload a return label was preselected | Check the shipping option before you create or approve; a Shopify label can't be voided |
| Looked at the Return in progress card | The main button read Process and refund; the Help Center calls this step Process return | It's the same step: that button opens Process return |
| Opened Process return | Deductions −$1.50, Refund owed $3.50, Refund amount prefilled at $3.50 | Process return takes the fees off the refund for you; check the amount before you click Process and refund |
| Opened Process return | Restock at was already ticked on both orders when we opened Process return, with a location filled in on the first | Check the Restock at box and location before you confirm |
| Opened the order's Refund screen before processing the return | Items locked under Return in progress, with a Refund and process return button; Refund amount $0.00, entered by hand; no fees applied | Before the return is processed, a refund from the order doesn't calculate the fees, so you enter the amount and subtract the fees yourself |
| Process return with Later, then the order's Refund screen | A banner said we owed the customer a refund; the Refund screen opened with Refund amount already filled in with the Refund owed, fees taken off by Process return | Choose Later and the fees still come off; check the filled-in amount before you click Refund |
Source: our Shopify development store, November 14, 2026.
- Orders
- Order details
- Return
- Orders
- Order details
- Refund
- Orders
- Order details
- Refund
The test didn't cover fees that come from return rules (ours were set by hand on the return), orders paid through Shopify Payments, or what happens once a refund is confirmed.
Received and Inspected: Process the Return
Key takeaway
Shopify's processing returns page puts the inspection first:
After you receive and inspect your return items, you need to process your return.
You don't have to process everything at once. Shopify lets you process a return either partially or all at the same time, depending on which return or exchange items you're ready to process, which helps when one parcel has arrived and another is still on its way.
- Orders
- Order details
- From Orders, open the order.
- In the Return in progress section, click Process return (see our test for the button label on that card).
- Under Return items to receive (Return item to confirm in our test admin as of November 14, 2026), select the items that arrived.
- Optional: to restock an item, select Restock at and choose the location.
- Under Exchange items to release, select the exchange items you're sending.
- Optional: refund shipping.
- Under Issue refund, choose Now or Later.
- Click Process and refund, or Process return if you chose Later.
In the Shopify mobile app, the same steps start with a tap on Process return.
- Orders
- Order details
- Process return
Shopify's processing returns page describes Restock at as an option: to restock a return item, you select Restock at and choose a location. On the Refund screen, Shopify's refunding page says Restock items is selected by default and is available only when you track inventory for the items in the order.
If there's no payment to refund on the order, Shopify lets you restock the items without creating a return or a refund.
What the restock box on the Refund screen does is covered in our answer on refunding an order in Shopify.
Choose Later to process the return first and refund the balance later from the order: Shopify's processing page says a banner shows the outstanding balance on the order and the amount you owe is added to the Refund amount when you refund.
- Orders
- Order details
- Process return
One return has up to three ways money can go back: the refund step inside Process return when you choose Now, a later refund of the balance Process return left on the order, and an ordinary refund from the order. The last two use the same Refund screen.
Process return carries a box that emails the customer once the refund is finalized, and Shopify's refunding page says the box on the Refund screen is selected by default; with Later, Process return sends no notification.
If you don't want the email to go out, clear the box on whichever screen you confirm. Our answer on whether Shopify emails the customer when you refund goes through the email itself.
Shipping can be refunded too, except on orders with an order-level free shipping discount applied.
Money Back, Store Credit or an Exchange?
Key takeaway
When Process return asks how to refund, the Refund method drop-down offers three answers: Original payment, Store credit, or Original payment & store credit. Exchange items, added when you approve or create the return, are the fourth route, and they settle the difference instead of refunding everything.
Four ways to settle a return
| Route | Pick it when | Boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Original payment | The customer wants the money back on the method they paid with | Once issued from the admin, the refund can't be canceled or reversed |
| Store credit | The customer agrees to credit they'll spend in your store | Less than $15,000 USD per customer account; not on legacy customer accounts; spent only as the full amount |
| Original payment & store credit | You split the refund between the payment method and credit | Staff without both refund permissions don't see the Refund method choice |
| Exchange items | The customer wants a different item instead of money | No custom items; none on orders with duties; the new item's stock isn't reserved until you process the return |
Source: Shopify Help Center pages on processing returns, creating returns, refunding orders and store credit, read November 14, 2026.
Store credit's limits are in the table, starting with less than $15,000 USD of store credit on a single customer account, and our store credit guide lists where store credit won't work.
With exchange items on the return, Shopify works out the money automatically. You owe the customer when the returning items are worth more than the new items and fees; the customer owes you when the new items and fees are more expensive than the returning items; and an even exchange settles at zero.
On the Shopify Plus plan, the exchanges feature is activated through the feature test drive.
If you'd rather ship a new item without taking anything back, that's a different procedure: sending a replacement order on Shopify.
On orders processed through Shopify Payments, a refund doesn't return your credit card fees, and our answer on whether Shopify refunds transaction fees covers what a third-party provider's fee gets back.
What You Can't Undo, and the Way Forward
Key takeaway
Most of a return can be adjusted until the money moves. The refund itself is the hard stop, and Shopify's refunding page states it without qualification:
You can't cancel or reverse a refund after you initiate a refund from your Shopify admin.
Steps you can't take back
| Action | Can you undo it? | The way forward |
|---|---|---|
| Issue a refund | No, it can't be canceled or reversed | If it was a mistake, create a new draft order and collect the payment again with it |
| Refund before creating the return | No, you can't create a return after a refund has been issued | The refund stands without a return reason; create the return first on the next order |
| Create a Shopify return label | No, return labels can't be voided | An unused label expires, and pay-on-scan billing charges you only once the carrier scans it |
| Cancel a return | No, a canceled return can't be reopened | Create a new return |
| Refund to store credit, then refund to the card | No, over-refunding doesn't automatically remove the store credit already issued | Settle the refund method before you refund; over-refunding is available on Shopify Payments orders with the Over-refund orders previously refunded to store credit permission, and if you don't want the customer to keep both, decrease their store credit balance by the amount you refund to the card |
| Partially refund the order | The refund stands, and the customer can still initiate a chargeback for the full value of the order | Keep the order's evidence ready; our guide to Shopify chargebacks covers how disputes are answered |
Source: Shopify Help Center pages on refunding orders, return labels and processing returns, read November 14, 2026.
- Orders
- Order details
- Cancel return
Canceling a Return: The Five Conditions
Key takeaway
Canceling a return removes a return that you created. Shopify separates it from canceling an order, which halts order processing before items ship. You can cancel a return only when all of these hold:
- It hasn't been refunded.
- It hasn't been restocked.
- It's open and hasn't been marked as returned.
- It has no return label.
- The fulfillment for the return hasn't been canceled.
To cancel a return with exchange items, cancel the return, and then edit the order to remove the unfulfilled exchange items.
If only part of the parcel arrives, or an item is missing, you don't have to cancel the whole return. Remove return items takes items off it, as long as they haven't been refunded or restocked.
- Orders
- Order details
When the Return Closes and What Your Reports Show
Key takeaway
A return closes automatically when every item is processed and every return item is restocked, and after you complete all outstanding tasks, you can also close it yourself with Close return in the Return in progress card's menu. When you exchange items, you don't need to refund every item unless you owe money to your customer.
- Orders
- Order details
Processing is also what moves the numbers. When Shopify introduced it, its changelog said “Our new returns processing feature puts you in control of when returns impact your sales and tax reports.” If a returned order still looks unchanged in your reports, check whether the return has been processed.
One knock-on effect reaches the counter. Shopify's POS exchange page says that if an order already has a return in progress from the Shopify admin, you can't exchange it on Shopify POS until the return is closed. Our guide to returns on Shopify POS covers the in-store side.
When Your Return Takes a Different Path
Key takeaway
Everything above assumes an online order with an ordinary payment. These situations change a step:
Returns that change the path
| Situation | What changes |
|---|---|
| EU consumer orders | EU countries apply Directive (EU) 2023/2673, which requires an electronic way to withdraw, from June 19, 2026. Shopify's return rules page says that for EU orders you need to issue refunds within 14 days of the cancellation request, so process EU requests promptly. |
| EU orders on Shopify Managed Markets | Since July 16, 2026, Managed Markets supports EU buyer cancellation and return requests: applicable EU orders get a 14-day cancellation and return rule managed by Global-e, and merchants are responsible for procuring return labels. |
| Final-sale items | Customers can't submit return or cancellation requests for them, unless both your return rules and your cancellation rules were turned off when the item was purchased, and a return window override doesn't change that. The pages we read on November 14, 2026 don't say what the admin does when you create a return for one by hand. |
| Customers who paid with OXXO or Multibanco | See how to refund a customer who paid with OXXO or Multibanco. |
Source: Shopify Help Center return rules page, Shopify Changelog and EUR-Lex (Directive (EU) 2023/2673), read November 14, 2026.
These answers are not in the Shopify documentation we read on November 14, 2026:
- a deadline after which a customer's return request closes, declines or approves on its own;
- what the admin shows when you create a return by hand for a final-sale item or outside the return window (the return rules page says return rules still apply when you process returns manually, but not what the admin shows);
- a built-in automatic approval of return requests.
We read Shopify's Help Center pages on returns and exchanges, self-serve requests, return rules, refunding and canceling orders, return labels, customer store credit and the Flow Return requested trigger, Shopify's changelog, and Shopify's blog article on ecommerce returns. The absence is the finding: if one of these matters to your store, check it in your own admin.
Return Run Sheet: Request to Refund
Key takeaway
Steps one to three happen when the customer gets in touch and steps four to eight when the parcel arrives.
Run an online return from request to refundTick each step as you settle it. Progress is saved in this browser.
Run an online return from request to refund
Tick each step as you settle it. Progress is saved in this browser.
Find out whether the order has a self-serve request or the customer wrote to you, and confirm the items are fulfilled and not yet refunded.
Before you tick this off
- You know whether it's a return request, a cancellation request or a message
- The items are fulfilled and haven't been refunded
Approve or decline the request from Review request, or create the return yourself with Return, before any refund.
Before you tick this off
- Any exchange items are added now, because customers can't request them
- A decline message has been read before sending
- No refund has been issued on these items yet
Pick a Shopify return label, an uploaded label or No shipping required; a Shopify return label can't be voided.
Before you tick this off
- A Shopify label is only for domestic US or Canadian returns
- The package weight matches the items actually coming back
Wait for the parcel and check what came back before you process anything.
Before you tick this off
- Every item on the return is accounted for
- Missing items are taken off with Remove return items
In Return in progress, open Process return (our test admin's button read Process and refund), select the items received and choose Restock at with a location for anything going back on sale.
Before you tick this off
- Only the items you received are selected
- Restock at is set for each item going back on sale
Pick Now or Later and the refund method: original payment, store credit or both.
Before you tick this off
- Store credit stays under the per-account limit and the customer isn't on legacy customer accounts
- Exchange differences are settled in the right direction
Before you confirm, check the Refund amount against the fees you set and decide whether the customer notification goes out.
Before you tick this off
- The Refund amount reflects your restocking and return shipping fees
- The notification box is set the way you want
Check that the return closed once every item was processed and every return item restocked; after you complete all outstanding tasks, you can also close it yourself with Close return in the Return in progress card's menu.
Before you tick this off
- Nothing is left to process on the return
- Exchange items have been released
The Bottom Line
Key takeaway
Shopify's built-in returns cover the whole run for online orders, from the customer's request to the refund, as long as you keep the steps in order: the return before the refund, the label only when you're sure, and the fees checked on screen while Shopify's two pages disagree about them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Front-end developer specializing in Shopify since 2017. Experienced in building custom Liquid themes, optimizing storefront performance, and integrating third-party apps. Directs the editorial process behind Ecom Store Pro: sets its topics and the rules every AI-written page must pass before publication.
This page was written by AI. Separate AI agents that did not write it check its figures and claims against official sources and test its links and interactive tools. A human editor sets the site's editorial direction, topics and rules and checks that pages are complete and display correctly, but does not check their facts or edit their text. Details may change — always confirm critical data at shopify.com.
Editorial PolicySome links in this article are affiliate links. If you sign up for a Shopify store through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our full advertising policy.
