Ecom Store Pro

What does "Return label not sent" mean on an existing Shopify return?

Updated ·
At a glance
Short answer
It appears when you add a label to a return made without one; fix: add a free custom item, fulfill it, make a new return with the label.
Creating the label in Shopify
Only if you have a location in the customer's country, and it is the US or Canada; otherwise upload one.
Label created but never received
A separate job: resend it from the return's label details — email, copy link or print.
Order total
Unchanged: Shopify's editing rules say a custom item with a 0 price doesn't change it.
Reports
An edit made after the day the order was placed shows as a separate order in reports.
What's New Since Publication: Updated since publication · 2 changes
  1. Shopify return labels now work from Canada too
    Shopify's Creating returns help page, read October 24, 2026, says Create a return label in Shopify needs a location in the same country as the customer's shipping address, and that country can be the United States or Canada. This page previously said both addresses had to be in the US.
  2. Shopify's order-editing page now names the button Custom item
    Shopify's order-editing help page, read October 17, 2026, says to click Custom item on desktop (tap Add custom item in the Shopify app). This page previously said + Add custom item. The workaround's steps are unchanged.

When does Shopify show "Return label not sent"?

You may see Return label not sent when you try to add a return label to an existing return. Per Shopify's return-label guide, it happens when you "initially created a return without a shipping label and later tried to add one."

If the label exists but never reached the customer, resend it instead: in the order's Return label section, click View details, then Email customer, Copy link or Print label.

How do you add a return label to an existing Shopify return?

Shopify's workaround puts the label on a new return instead:

  1. Edit the order and click Custom item (in the Shopify app, tap Add custom item) to add a free custom item named "Return shipping label".
  2. Fulfill the free item.
  3. Create a new return for that custom item.
  4. While creating it, immediately upload or create the return label (see which carriers Shopify can create it with).

If step 1 is blocked, see why Shopify blocked that edit. You can create a return only for fulfilled items that haven't been refunded.

Creating the label in Shopify at step 4 works only if you have a location in the same country as the customer's shipping address, and that country is the US or Canada; otherwise upload one as a PDF, PNG, JPEG or URL. For the label screen, see how to create a return label.

What does the workaround change on your Shopify order?

Per Shopify's general editing rules, a custom item with a 0 price doesn't change the order total. An edit made after the day the order was placed shows in reports as a separate order, and app data might be incorrect; order editing is more likely to affect fulfillment apps. If a 3PL fills the order, check what an edit sends it.

Shopify's four steps don't include any action on the first return. If you decide to cancel it, Shopify allows that only if it isn't refunded or restocked, is open and not Marked as returned, has no return label, and its fulfillment isn't canceled. It can't be reopened afterwards.

About This Article

This page was written by AI. Separate AI agents that did not write it check its figures and claims against official sources and test its links and interactive tools. A human editor sets the site's editorial direction, topics and rules and checks that pages are complete and display correctly, but does not check their facts or edit their text. Details may change — always confirm critical data at shopify.com.

Editorial Policy

Related questions

Shipping & fulfillment
Can your Shopify return address be a PO Box?

No for Shopify return labels: the location needs a valid US or Canadian street address, and UPS's return address for them can't be a PO Box.

Updated October 24, 2026

Orders & customers
Can you combine two orders in Shopify?

No Shopify page we read merges two orders: edit the first to add the items if it's still editable, or re-create both as one draft.

October 26, 2026

Shipping & fulfillment
Is there an official PostNL app for Shopify?

Yes — PostNL's own Dutch-only app adds return labels, Belgium and (on Grow and up) checkout pickup points that PostNL in Shopify Shipping lacks.

October 30, 2026

Stay updated

Get notified about new articles

Subscribe to receive updates when we publish new Shopify guides and insights.