Ecom Store Pro

Who handles a dispute on a Shop Pay Installments order?

Published ·
At a glance
Short answer
Affirm decides. Shopify's FAQ gives you 15 days from Affirm's dispute email to send evidence; Shopify's help pages differ on where that notice lands.
Evidence window
15 days from Affirm's dispute email, then Affirm resolves within another 15 days
Disputed funds
Shopify's FAQ: held up to 30 days; wins go to your Shopify Payments bank account, losses to the customer
Where the notice lands
FAQ: Affirm email only. Getting-paid page: admin notification plus email. Compared November 20, 2026
How to respond
Getting-paid page: Open response on admin notification or email. FAQ: reply to the email. Affirm's direct-merchant pages: replies aren't supported

Who decides a Shop Pay Installments dispute?

Affirm. Per Shopify's Shop Pay Installments FAQ, once a payment is successfully captured, the customer can open a dispute with Affirm, which resolves it.

How long do you have, and what happens to the money?

Once Affirm's dispute email arrives, Shopify's FAQ gives you 15 days to reply with evidence. Shopify's FAQ adds that Affirm then resolves the dispute within another 15 days, holding the disputed funds during that 30-day period.

A win releases the funds to the bank account you use for Shopify Payments. If Affirm sides with your customer, the FAQ says:

If Affirm resolves the dispute in favor of your customer, then the disputed funds are returned to the customer. There's no additional cost to you if the customer is refunded.
Shopify — Shop Pay Installments FAQ, Shopify Help Center ·

Where does the dispute notice arrive?

The FAQ and Shopify's page on getting paid disagree, as read on November 20, 2026:

Shop Pay Installments FAQ
  • “Affirm emails your Shopify store owner” — no notification in your Shopify admin.
  • Reply “directly to the email”.
Getting paid page
  • “a notification in your Shopify admin and an email”
  • Respond with Open response on the admin notification or the email.
  • Managed like Shopify Payments disputes.

Until the pages agree, watch both the store owner's inbox and your admin. If the dispute shows in your admin, use Open response, the route the getting-paid page documents.

If only the email arrives, look for Open response in it before you hit reply: Affirm's dispute pages for merchants it contracts with directly say “replies to the email are not supported”, though the ones we read on November 15, 2026 don't mention Shop Pay or Shopify.

Affirm's Business Hub calls Shop Pay Installments “in fact a Shopify product” and says that if you have a Shop Pay Installments integration, Shopify's support team is best suited to answer any inquiries you may have, so when the email's instructions don't settle how to respond, ask Shopify Support.

About This Article

This page was written by AI. Separate AI agents that did not write it check its figures and claims against official sources and test its links and interactive tools. A human editor sets the site's editorial direction, topics and rules and checks that pages are complete and display correctly, but does not check their facts or edit their text. Details may change — always confirm critical data at shopify.com.

Editorial Policy

Related questions

Payments & payouts
How do you add the Shop Pay Installments banner to a Shopify product page?

Horizon: a Price block toggle; themes not showing the banner yet: the payment_terms filter in the product form. Needs Shop Pay Installments on.

November 18, 2026

Payments & payouts
How do you turn on Shop Pay in Shopify?

Check Shop Pay in Settings > Payments; on another gateway, add Shopify Payments where supported, or enable Shop Pay for it if your store is eligible.

November 10, 2026

Payments & payouts
Does Shop Pay Installments check your customers' credit or report to credit bureaus?

Applying doesn't affect a customer's credit, say Shopify and Affirm, but payments on an accepted plan may be reported to a credit bureau.

November 14, 2026

Stay updated

Get notified about new articles

Subscribe to receive updates when we publish new Shopify guides and insights.