- Short answer
- Only if Recharge's tools earn back $149/mo + 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction on Starter; Shopify Subscriptions is free on Shopify Payments.
- Refunds
- Recharge's transaction fee still applies to refunded orders.
- Free trial
- Starter only; one per store, and it starts when you install Recharge.
- Starter or Scale
- Scale costs less on fees above $140,000 processed a month (our arithmetic).
- Alternatives
- Skio $599 billed monthly + 1.25% + 20¢ on subscription orders; Appstle 0% fee, free to $500/mo of subscription revenue.
- Leaving Recharge
- Cancel it before the new app goes live, or subscribers can be billed twice.
What does Recharge cost on Shopify?
Recharge's Starter plan costs $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction for stores that install Recharge on or after November 2, 2026, billed after a 60-day free trial. It is month-to-month, with no contract.
Recharge's Scale plan costs $499 a month plus 1.25% + 20¢ and adds features such as customized bundles, tiered discounts, gifting, subscriber-journey A/B testing and Concierge SMS. Custom is priced in a contract you generally can't cancel during its term. The old 25-50 plan is no longer available to new stores.
The percentage reaches further than subscriptions. Recharge charges it on:
- one-time orders as well as recurring subscription orders;
- the total processed amount, including shipping and taxes;
- refunded orders, because Recharge has already processed them.
That fee is separate from Shopify's and your payment processor's fees.
What does Recharge add over Shopify's free Subscriptions app?
Shopify's free first-party app bills weekly, monthly or yearly, applies subscription discounts, and lets customers manage their plan in their customer account. Shopify draws the line itself:
For simple subscription offerings try the free Shopify Subscriptions app or explore a collection of Shopify’s world-class subscriptions apps for more advanced needs.
Where the two apps differ
| Shopify Subscriptions (free) | Recharge | |
|---|---|---|
| Failed payments | Retries you schedule: attempts, days apart, then skip, pause or cancel, with a customer notification | Automatic retries on optimized timing, with customer notifications |
| Cancellations | Customers pause or cancel from their account | Cancellation Prevention flows with retention offers; A/B testing is listed under Scale |
| Analytics | Four in-app metrics (revenue, active, new, canceled subscriptions) plus subscription reports in Shopify Analytics | Performance, Revenue, Subscribers and Subscriptions dashboard categories |
| Customer portal | Customers manage subscriptions in their Shopify customer account | Recharge portal; its Unity theme runs on the Shopify account page |
| Bundles | Not compatible with the app | Customized bundles on the Scale plan |
Shopify Help Center pages on the Shopify Subscriptions app and Recharge's help center, read November 15, 2026.
On failed payments both apps retry and then stop: Shopify Subscriptions skips, pauses or cancels as you set it, and with Recharge's recovery strategy subscriptions cancel once every retry fails. The difference is how many renewals Recharge's optimized retry timing and notifications at key points in the recovery journey save before that. If failed renewals are your main loss, read how they turn into churn first.
Whether a subscription app's portal needs new customer accounts is a separate check.
Shopify's Subscriptions help pages we read on November 15, 2026 don't describe cancellation save flows, customers swapping products themselves, build-a-box, MRR or churn-rate reporting, or recovery SMS. Need one of them? Confirm it on the third-party app's listing.
Recharge vs Skio vs Appstle: price and fee model
Skio is now part of Recharge: Recharge acquired it in April 2026 and said both platforms would continue to operate as they have.
Their fees still differ. Skio's Scale plan is $599 a month on monthly billing, with its 1.25% + 20¢ charged only on orders involving a subscription. Appstle charges a 0% transaction fee and prices its plans by monthly subscription revenue, free up to $500 a month.
Monthly cost of each app
| App and plan | Monthly price | Transaction fee | Fee charged on | App bill at $20,000 in 500 orders (our arithmetic) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify Subscriptions | Free | None on Shopify Payments | No app transaction fee | $0 |
| Recharge Starter | $149 after a 60-day trial | 1.50% + 20¢ | All processed amounts | $549 |
| Recharge Scale | $499 | 1.25% + 20¢ | Same as Starter | $849 |
| Skio Scale | $599, or $499/mo billed yearly | 1.25% + 20¢ | Orders involving a subscription | $949 if every order has a subscription |
| Appstle Subscriptions | Free to $500; $10, $30 or $100 up to $5,000, $15,000 or $100,000 of subscription revenue a month | 0% | No app transaction fee | $100 (Business Premium) if all $20,000 is subscription revenue |
USD prices on the Shopify App Store listings and skio.com/pricing, read November 15, 2026. Payment processing fees are excluded from every row.
On Shopify Subscriptions the $0 holds on Shopify Payments; if you use a third-party payment provider instead, Shopify charges third-party transaction fees. The Help Center pages on the app we read on November 15, 2026 describe no separate Shopify fee for subscription orders beyond that.
For Seal, Loop, Bold and other apps, see our comparison of Shopify subscription apps.
When does Recharge pay for itself?
After Starter's 60-day free trial, Recharge always costs more than Shopify's free app, so the question is whether its tools keep more revenue than the bill. In the example above, Starter comes to $549 a month; the failed payments it recovers and the cancellations it saves have to be worth more than that. Against Appstle's bill in the same example the gap is $449 if the whole example volume is subscription revenue (our arithmetic), and Appstle's Business plans list retention and cancellation tools too, so compare features before you pay it.
Shopify Subscriptions already retries failed payments, so count only what Recharge recovers beyond those retries.
Between Recharge's own plans, our arithmetic gives one threshold: Scale's rate is 0.25 points lower for $350 more a month, so it costs less on fees once Recharge processes more than $140,000 a month. Below that, Recharge's Scale is for the extra features listed under its cost above.
Can you switch to or away from Recharge later?
Yes, in both directions; Recharge documents migrating to Recharge and migrating away. For a move to Shopify Subscriptions, Recharge Support can enable a Migr8-based tool that assists with it.
- A self-service tool moves subscribers from Appstle, Seal and other Shopify subscription platforms if you use one of Shopify's eligible subscription payment processors.
- CSV files process 5,000 rows at a time.
- Historical data and analytics are not migrated.
- Cancel Recharge before the new provider goes live, or customers can be billed twice.
- Recharge sends no built-in notice that subscriptions are ending.
- Shopify Subscriptions imports contracts only by CSV from a Shopify Checkout integrated app; next billing must be 24+ hours after import.
Ask Recharge which integration your store runs on before you plan the Shopify CSV import. Uninstalling a third-party subscription app keeps contracts and payment information, but deletes its other subscription data after 48 hours.
If you are weighing a smaller app as the destination, our Easy Subscriptions review covers one.
This page was written by AI. Separate AI agents that did not write it check its figures and claims against official sources and test its links and interactive tools. A human editor sets the site's editorial direction, topics and rules and checks that pages are complete and display correctly, but does not check their facts or edit their text. Details may change — always confirm critical data at shopify.com.
Editorial Policy