Recurring payments on Shopify: the free Subscriptions app vs Recharge, Appstle, Seal, Loop and Skio — real fees per plan, setup steps, and how to cut churn.
March 29, 2026·Updated July 2026·17 min read·
Affiliate Disclosure
Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you sign up for a Shopify store through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
2Four subscription models and which fits your business
3Shopify's free app vs top third-party apps
4Step-by-step setup guide (under 30 minutes)
5True cost breakdown: app fees + transaction fees
6Proven strategies to reduce subscriber churn
In This Article
Does Shopify Have Recurring Payments?
Key takeaway
Customers check out exactly like a one-time purchase, but with a recurring billing schedule attached. And with the right setup, subscriptions can become your most profitable revenue channel.
You can add subscriptions to your existing products without changing your store setup. Products can offer both one-time and subscription purchase options simultaneously — customers choose at checkout. Read our Easy Start guide if you're still setting up.
Subscription Models
Key takeaway
Shopify's documentation splits this two ways: three business models — curation (subscription boxes), replenishment, and access — and two billing models, pay-as-you-go and prepaid. The four groupings below combine those axes into the choices you actually configure in a selling plan.
Four Practical Subscription Models
Model
How It Works
Best For
Example
Subscribe & Save
Same product, auto-shipped on a schedule with a discount
Consumables, replenishment
Coffee, vitamins, pet food
Prepaid
Customer pays upfront for 3, 6, or 12 deliveries
Higher AOV, reduced churn
3-month tea box, seasonal boxes
Curated Box
Rotating product selection chosen by the merchant
Discovery, engagement
Snack box, beauty box
Membership Access
Recurring fee for exclusive perks, discounts, or content
Community, loyalty
VIP club, exclusive discounts, gated content
Hybrid approach
Many successful stores combine models. For example, a skincare brand might offer subscribe-and-save on individual products and a curated monthly box — giving customers flexibility while maximizing recurring revenue across different customer segments.
“You can add a subscription as a purchase option to sell products on a recurring basis, and customers can choose to pay an agreed price for your product in a scheduled frequency, such as monthly, weekly, or daily. Subscriptions can create predictable recurring revenue and build long-term customer relationships.”
Technically, subscriptions are powered by Shopify's Selling Plans API. When you install a subscription app, it creates selling plans that define three things:
What the App Controls
What You Set
Example
Billing frequency
How often to charge the customer
Every 30 days, every 2 weeks
Delivery schedule
When to fulfill and ship
Same day as billing, pre-ship 3 days early
Subscriber discount
Price adjustment for subscribers
15% off, $5 flat discount, same price
Each recurring charge creates a standard Shopify order — meaning subscription orders flow through your normal fulfillment process and appear in your regular order reports.
“Subscriptions enable customers to purchase products on a recurring basis. […] Subscription apps enable developers and merchants to build subscription experiences directly into Shopify's ecosystem.”
Customers are charged automatically on their selected schedule — weekly, monthly, or custom intervals.
Customer Portal
Self-service portal for subscribers to manage, skip, pause, swap, or cancel subscriptions.
Dunning Management
Automatic payment retry logic and failed payment recovery emails to reduce involuntary churn.
Subscription Analytics
Track MRR, churn rate, subscriber growth, and lifetime value across all subscription products.
Subscription Discounts
Offer subscribe-and-save discounts, tiered pricing, or prepaid bundles to incentivize commitment.
Product Swaps
Let subscribers swap products between deliveries — ideal for variety boxes and curated subscriptions.
Shopify's Free Subscriptions App
Key takeaway
The Shopify Subscriptions app is built by Shopify and is listed as free — no monthly plan fee and no app transaction fees, although Shopify notes that a particular setup may still involve additional fees. It's the simplest way to add recurring payments to your store.
What It Does
Subscribe-and-save with percentage or fixed discounts
Weekly, monthly, or yearly billing cycles
Customer self-management (pause, skip, cancel)
Customizable email templates
POS subscription sales
Subscription performance reporting
Migrate existing contracts from other apps
Digital and physical product subscriptions
What It Lacks
Advanced dunning / failed payment recovery flows
Cancellation save offers (discount to stay)
Subscription box / curated box support
Dynamic product bundles
Upsell and cross-sell tools
Loyalty / rewards for subscribers
Advanced analytics and benchmarks
Tiered or usage-based pricing models
None of these appear in the app's published feature list — Shopify documents no dunning or save-flow behaviour for it.
If you have fewer than 50 subscribers, sell simple replenishment products (like supplements or coffee), and don't need advanced retention tools — the free app works fine. Upgrade to a paid app when churn becomes a problem or you need bundles.
Recharge powers subscriptions for thousands of DTC brands. Its key differentiators:
Dynamic bundles — customers build their own subscription box
Cancellation prevention — automated save flows with offers
Failed payment recovery — smart dunning with retry logic
Unified checkout — subscription + one-time items in a single cart
Analytics & benchmarks — compare your metrics against industry averages
Integrations with Klaviyo, Gorgias, Stripe, Attentive
Recharge's entry-level 25-50 plan is $25/month for up to 50 subscribers with no transaction fees. Starter is $99/month + 1.49% + 19¢ per transaction for scaling stores, and Plus is $499/month + 1.34% + 19¢. The 25-50 and Starter plans include a 60-day free trial; the Plus plan card doesn't list one.
Appstle — Best Free Tier
Appstle Subscriptions is the highest-rated subscription app (5.0★, 7,900+ reviews as of July 2026) with a genuinely useful free tier — supporting up to $500/month in subscription revenue with no transaction fees. Paid plans start from $10/month.
Seal Subscriptions — Simplest Setup
Key takeaway
Seal Subscriptions is popular for its simplicity — 4.9★ rating (2,800+ reviews as of July 2026), free plan covering up to 50 subscriptions. Paid plans start at $5.95/month. Best for stores that just need basic subscribe-and-save without complex features.
Shopify Subscriptions Tutorial for Beginners (2026)Step-by-step walkthrough of setting up recurring payments on Shopify, covering the native Subscriptions app and key configuration options.
What Changed in 2026
Key takeaway
Subscription tooling moved between spring and summer 2026. Every item below is dated and comes from a first-party source, so you can tell today's reality from an older guide:
Recharge acquired Skio (announced April 30, 2026) — the Recharge announcement says the two are "together powering 20,000+ brands and $20B in annual GMV" and that "Both platforms continue operating as normal, with a combined roadmap." The App Store listing now reads Skio, a Recharge Company — so a Recharge-versus-Skio shortlist is really two products from one vendor.
New default subscription disclosure at checkout (effective June 22, 2026) — the checkout disclosure changelog (posted June 17) introduces new translation keys for the subscription agreement label, consent text, and cancellation instructions, and states that from June 22 the default disclosure is shown if no customizations have been made. If you rewrote that checkout copy, re-check what buyers see now.
Higher Built for Shopify bar for subscription apps (deadline December 1, 2026) — per the developer changelog, subscription apps that provide buyer-facing self-service experiences must authenticate customers using the Customer Account API; apps that miss the deadline risk losing Built for Shopify status. Worth asking any app you shortlist how far along it is.
Migration got easier (API version 2026-04, dated April 1, 2026) — the payment method ID is no longer required when creating subscription contracts, which per the 2026-04 changelog note "allows you to migrate subscription contracts even if they have missing or expired payment methods." That directly softens the migration risks below.
App Store standings moved (March to July 2026) — Appstle went from roughly 6,300 to 7,900 reviews, Recharge from 2,100 to 2,900, Seal from 2,600 to 2,900, and Loop from 300 to 675 with its rating rising to 5.0. Shopify's own app climbed from 3.5★ (567 reviews) to 3.7★ (734). Loop also now runs a Free Forever tier for up to 50 active subscriptions, which the comparison table above doesn't show.
True Cost Analysis
Key takeaway
Understanding the true cost of subscription apps requires stacking three layers of fees:
Fee Stack: What You Actually Pay
Fee Layer
Free App
Recharge Starter
Loop Starter
Shopify plan
$39–$399/mo
$39–$399/mo
$39–$399/mo
App monthly fee
$0
$99/mo
$99/mo
App transaction fee
None
1.49% + 19¢
1%
Shopify Payments fee
2.9% + 30¢ (Basic)
2.9% + 30¢ (Basic)
2.9% + 30¢ (Basic)
Combined effective rate
~2.9%
~4.4%
~3.9%
Calculated from published app pricing as of July 2026. Includes $99/mo base fee + per-transaction fees. Does not include Shopify Payments processing fees.
When paid apps pay for themselves
A paid app's dunning and cancellation prevention exist to win back revenue you already earned — Recharge's pricing page claims it can "recover up to 88% of failed payments" (a vendor claim, not an independent benchmark). Run the numbers on your own base: with 200 subscribers at $40/month, every 1% of monthly churn you prevent is worth $80 — so a $99/month app pays for itself well before it saves 5% of them. See our full pricing guide for more cost context.
Step-by-Step Setup Guide
Key takeaway
This guide uses Shopify Subscriptions (free) as the reference, but the process is nearly identical for Recharge, Appstle, and other apps.
1
Install a subscription app
Go to the Shopify App Store and install Shopify Subscriptions (free) or a third-party app like Recharge, Appstle, or Seal Subscriptions.
2
Create a selling plan
Define your subscription offer: frequency (weekly, monthly, yearly), discount type (percentage or fixed amount), and delivery schedule.
3
Attach to products
Select which products or variants should offer the subscription purchase option. Products can offer both one-time and subscription purchases.
4
Configure customer portal
Set up the self-service portal where subscribers can skip, pause, swap products, or cancel. Customize branding to match your store.
5
Set up email notifications
Configure order confirmation, upcoming charge reminders, payment failure alerts, and subscription renewal emails.
6
Test the full flow
Place a test subscription order, verify the checkout experience, confirm the recurring billing triggers, and check that the customer portal works.
Test before launching
Always place at least one test subscription order using Shopify's test mode before going live. Verify that the recurring charge triggers correctly, the customer portal works, and notification emails are sent.
Reducing Subscriber Churn
Key takeaway
Churn is the silent killer of subscription businesses. Every cancelled subscription has to be replaced before your base grows at all, so your churn rate quietly sets the ceiling on how big a subscriber base you can hold. Measure your own rate first — published "industry averages" for e-commerce subscriptions come from vendor blogs, not from Shopify or any primary study.
Voluntary Churn (Customer Cancels)
Key takeaway
Strategy
How It Works
Impact
Skip / Pause
Let customers skip a delivery or pause their subscription instead of cancelling
Reduces cancellations significantly
Cancellation save flow
When a customer clicks "cancel," offer a discount, free gift, or frequency change
Keeps some would-be cancellations active
Product swaps
Let subscribers change products between deliveries without cancelling
Reduces "boredom" churn
Pre-charge emails
Notify customers 3–5 days before each charge so they can modify or skip
Reduces chargebacks and surprise complaints
Loyalty rewards
Reward long-term subscribers with increasing discounts or exclusive perks
Increases retention after 3+ months
Involuntary Churn (Payment Fails)
Key takeaway
A meaningful share of subscription churn is involuntary — caused by expired cards, insufficient funds, or bank declines. Nobody publishes a primary figure for how large that share is, but this is the churn you can fix with technology:
Smart retries — apps like Recharge retry failed charges at optimal times (e.g., after payday)
Card auto-updater — Shopify Payments works with major card networks to refresh saved card details automatically; the feature is widely supported in the United States, with international coverage varying
Recovery emails — automated emails asking customers to update their payment method
SMS recovery — text notifications for failed payments (Recharge Plus plan)
Shopify's free app has basic dunning only
The native Shopify Subscriptions app publishes no dunning or save-flow features at all. Once failed payments and cancellations cost you more each month than a paid app does, the upgrade pays for itself — so track both numbers before you decide.
Limitations & Gotchas
Key takeaway
Platform Limitations
Bundles aren't compatible with the Shopify Subscriptions app
Gift cards apply to the first subscription payment only, not to later renewals
Customers can't use local payment methods on a subscription
The order editing API doesn't support subscription orders
Subscription products show selling plan info only on themes that support it
Draft orders don't support selling plans
Some payment gateways don't support recurring charges
Migration Risks
Switching apps can cause billing gaps or duplicate charges if not handled carefully
How payment methods carry over isn't guaranteed across every app — Shopify documents a migration path, but confirm it with both vendors
Historical subscription data (analytics, LTV) doesn't always migrate
Customer portal URLs change — update all email templates
Missing or expired cards used to stall a move — since API version 2026-04 those contracts can be migrated too
Before installing any subscription app, verify your theme supports selling plans. Every Online Store 2.0 theme built by Shopify — including the Horizon family — supports them; vintage free themes need Debut 15.0 or later or Brooklyn 17.0 or later. For third-party themes, check the Shopify theme subscription docs or contact your theme developer.
The Bottom Line
Key takeaway
Recurring payments on Shopify are app-powered — that's both a limitation (you need to choose an app) and an advantage (you pick the tool that matches your business stage).
Start now. Even a basic subscribe-and-save with 10% off can transform one-time buyers into recurring customers. Don't wait for the perfect app — validate demand first, optimize later.
Yes, but only through apps. Shopify provides a free Subscriptions app and also supports third-party subscription apps through the Selling Plans API. Recurring billing is not a built-in core feature of the Shopify platform — you must install an app to enable it.
As of July 2026, Appstle Subscriptions (5.0★, 7,900+ reviews) and Seal Subscriptions (4.9★, 2,800+ reviews) both offer free plans with no transaction fees — rated higher than Shopify's own free app (3.7★). Appstle's free tier is limited to $500/month in subscription revenue. Seal's free plan supports up to 50 subscriptions. For stores just starting, either is a better choice than the native Shopify app.
Recharge publishes three standard plans plus a volume-based Custom tier: the 25-50 plan at $25/month for your first 50 subscribers (no transaction fees), Starter at $99/month plus 1.49% + 19¢ per transaction, and Plus at $499/month plus 1.34% + 19¢ per transaction. The 25-50 and Starter plans include a 60-day free trial; the Plus plan card doesn't list one.
Yes. Shopify's Selling Plans system allows products to have both one-time and subscription purchase options simultaneously. Customers see a toggle or dropdown on the product page to choose between a single purchase and a recurring subscription (often with a subscribe-and-save discount).
The four main models are: subscribe-and-save (replenishment — best for consumables), prepaid subscriptions (pay upfront for multiple deliveries — higher AOV), curated/subscription boxes (rotating product selections — high engagement), and membership access (exclusive content or perks — digital or hybrid). The right model depends on your product type and customer behavior.
Key strategies include: enabling skip/pause instead of cancel-only, adding cancellation save flows (offer a discount or free gift), implementing dunning management for failed payments (automatic retries + recovery emails), allowing product swaps between deliveries, and sending pre-charge notification emails so customers aren't surprised by charges.
Yes. Shopify's native Subscriptions app and Recharge both support selling subscriptions through Shopify POS, so customers can sign up in-store while recurring billing runs online. Shopify documents the requirements: POS app 10.13 or later, POS UI extensions API 2025-10 or later, and Shopify Payments enabled. Existing selling plan contracts must still be managed through the online store — you can't manage them directly on POS.
The Shopify Subscriptions app documents five supported gateways: Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen, and Stripe. Availability varies by region and by app, so confirm before you commit. Shopify Payments gives the smoothest experience because saved card details are refreshed automatically by the card networks, which reduces failed payments.
Yes, but it requires careful planning. Most premium apps (Recharge, Appstle, Loop) offer migration tools to import existing subscription contracts, and Shopify publishes a Subscription API migration guide plus a walkthrough for migrating existing subscription contracts to Shopify; the native app documents import and export of contracts. Since API version 2026-04, contracts can be created without a payment method, so subscriptions with missing or expired cards can still be migrated. Confirm with both vendors how payment methods carry over, and watch for billing gaps or duplicate charges during the switch.
It depends on the app. Shopify's native app and some free-tier apps charge no additional transaction fees. Recharge charges 1.49% + 19¢ per transaction on their Starter plan. These fees are in addition to your standard Shopify Payments processing fees (2.9% + 30¢ on Basic). Always calculate the combined cost.
Yes. Every recurring charge creates a standard Shopify order. This means subscription orders are subject to the same Shopify Payments processing fees, appear in your regular order reports, and can be managed through Shopify's standard order management tools.
The app retries the charge and sends failed payment recovery emails to the customer. Shopify doesn't publish a retry schedule — each app sets its own, and Loop's App Store listing, for example, advertises smart dunning management with 15 retries. If the card on file has expired, Shopify Payments' automatic card updates may refresh the details. If every retry fails, the subscription is paused or cancelled depending on your settings.
Front-end developer specializing in Shopify since 2017. Experienced in building custom Liquid themes, optimizing storefront performance, and integrating third-party apps. Directs the editorial process behind Shopify Ecom: sets each topic, and checks facts, links, and interactive elements before publication.
This article was written entirely by AI under human editorial direction. The editor sets the topic and structure, runs multi-stage validation on facts, links, and interactive elements, and verifies the output is useful from a business perspective. All claims are checked against official Shopify sources. Details may change — always confirm critical data at shopify.com.
