Ecom Store Pro

How to Start a Trading Card Business on Shopify

Run a trading card store on Shopify: singles as condition variants, TCGplayer and eBay fees, one inventory across channels, pre-orders and safe shipping.

Listen to a short brief of this article
Hands-free while you multitask

The short version

You can run a trading card store on Shopify by listing each single as one product with a variant for every condition, giving graded slabs a quantity of one, and feeding your own store and the marketplaces from one inventory.

On a $100 card, before shipping and tax, TCGplayer's fees come to $13.55 for a seller at Level 1 to 4 and eBay's to $13.65, while Shopify Payments on Basic, at the standard card rate, takes $3.20 in your own store, which pays a monthly plan instead of a commission.

Release pre-orders need an app from the Shopify App Store, and if a release is late, Shopify's pre-order requirements oblige you to give the buyer a revised date and explain their right to cancel or get a refund.

A valuable card ships tracked and insured, up to $5,000 on a Shopify label for shipments from the US; USPS First Class Mail isn't eligible for that insurance, so keep it for cheap singles.

What Will Your Trading Card Store Sell?

Key takeaway

A trading card shop sells three different things, and Shopify handles each one differently. Find your row, then jump to the section that carries most of your work.

Find your row: what you sell decides the setup
What you sellHow it lives in ShopifyWhere the risk sitsRead next
Sealed product: booster boxes, packs, bundlesOne product per item with tracked stock; new releases sold ahead of time through a pre-order appA release that arrives late or short, after you promised a datePre-orders for new releases
Singles: individual raw cardsOne product per card, a variant for each condition, each with its own price and stockPrices that move daily, thousands of variants, and the same card listed on several channelsHow to list singles by condition
Graded slabsOne product per slab, inventory tracked, quantity 1Selling the same slab twice, or a high-value parcel lost without tracking, insurance or a signatureGraded slabs
A mix of the threeBoth models in one catalogBoth sets of risks, plus pre-orders that never run at a POS counterTake the quiz

The store itself, with its domain, theme, checkout and policies, is built like any Shopify store, and our guide to building a Shopify website covers that part. This article spends its length on what only a card shop has to solve.

Where the Inventory Comes From

Key takeaway

If you plan to sell Magic: The Gathering product through the publisher's retailer program or run its events, the route is Wizards Play Network (WPN). Its application guide for the US and Canada, read on November 17, 2026, sets these conditions among others, alongside business documents and a video tour showing signage and Magic product displays:

  • Open for business. Not under construction or still being set up.
  • A space of its own. The store should not share space with or be located inside another business.
  • Room to play. A dedicated play space with seating for eight or more players.

That makes WPN a program for a counter: a store that exists only online can't meet the play-space condition as written. Requirements may vary outside the US and Canada, where stores should follow the same guide unless their regional WPN team directs otherwise.

We ask that WPN applications only be submitted if your store is open for business, not currently under construction or in the process of being set up.
Wizards of the Coast — How to apply to WPN — Wizards Play Network ·

Play! Pokémon also works through registered stores. Pokémon's page for event organizers says Play! Pokémon store owners can host Prerelease events where players get new Pokémon TCG expansions two weeks before their street date, and that in selected markets eligible stores can join an Early Release Program for regular products.

Pokémon publishes its store requirements separately; check them before you plan around either program.

For one practitioner's view of starting a card business on a small budget, including card shows and money management, the card shop Murph's Card Town gave its advice in a 2024 video. It is one seller's opinion; the program rules above come from Wizards and Pokémon.

Looking to Start Your Own Trading Card Business? Watch This!Murph's Card Town on starting a card business: low-cost startup strategies, card shows and vendor tips, financial management. One practitioner's view, 2024.

Which Trading Card Store Are You Building?

The table at the top answers by product; this answers by combination: what you sell, how many singles, how many channels, whether you take pre-orders and whether customers buy at a counter. Five questions give you one route and the sections to read first.

Which trading card store are you building?Five questions, one route: the setup to build first and the sections that matter most for you
Which trading card store are you building?Five questions, one route: the setup to build first and the sections that matter most for you
Question 1 of 5
What will most of your sales be?

How to List Singles by Condition

Key takeaway

Singles are where a card shop differs most from an ordinary store: the same card exists in several conditions at several prices, and a busy shop lists thousands of them. Three decisions shape the catalog.

Condition, Printing and Language as Three Options

Key takeaway

In Shopify's product taxonomy, the Gaming Cards category under Collectible Trading Cards carries the attributes Card attributes, Condition, Grading, Rarity, Recommended age group and Trading card packaging.

In the product's Variants card, click Add options like size or color and, if the Condition category metafield is offered, select it; the option values then fill from its entries. Shopify's taxonomy gives Condition 16 default values, among them Mint (M), Near mint (NM), Excellent (EX), Good (G), Graded and Other.

TCGplayer's scale doesn't line up with that list. TCGplayer sorts cards into five conditions: Near Mint, Lightly Played, Moderately Played, Heavily Played and Damaged.

Lightly, Moderately and Heavily Played aren't among Shopify's 16 values, so you add them yourself. Shopify's category metafields page says "Category metafields have default entries that you can either use as is or customize further." A custom entry is added with Add new entry. The frame below comes from our test admin on November 18, 2026, with Condition values Near mint (NM) and Lightly played.

In Shopify adminOpen in your store
  1. Products
  2. Variants
Near mint (NM) is a default entry and Lightly played was added by hand; each is its own variant.

Condition takes one of the 3 options a product can have, which leaves two for printing (foil or non-foil, say) and language.

A product holds up to 2,048 variants, a ceiling Shopify raised from 100 in October 2025. The higher ceiling isn't universal: Shopify's help page warns that some third-party themes "might not support more than 100 variants", and that some theme app extensions, public apps and sales channels might not either. Test your theme and every channel app on a large product before you import singles at scale.

Stores with 500,000 or more variants that upload through an app or CSV import also meet a daily limit of 10,000 new variants, except on Shopify Plus; our variant limits section explains it.

Graded Slabs: One Product, Quantity One

Key takeaway

A graded card is one physical item, so give it a product of its own rather than a variant of the raw card, track its inventory and set the quantity to 1. Shopify's inventory setup page states the default you want: "When a product reaches zero inventory, customers can't add it to their cart."

The setting that controls this is labelled Sell when out of stock in the product editor, and its on-state is Continue selling when out of stock. Leave it off on every slab.

In Shopify adminOpen in your store
  1. Products
  2. Inventory
One unit in stock and Sell when out of stock off, so the slab can't be sold twice online.

One exception matters if you also sell in person: Shopify says the continue-selling option doesn't apply to Shopify POS, so a cashier can still ring up a slab the website already sold. Resale shops run the same one-of-one model, and our resale guide's unique-item tech setup walks through it for a whole catalog.

When to Hand Singles to a TCG Inventory App

Key takeaway

A few hundred singles fit Shopify's own editor. A catalog that grows by a set at a time needs imports and repricing, which is what these listings offer. We found these three on the Shopify App Store; treat them as a snapshot of November 17 and 18, 2026, not a complete list.

Three App Store listings for card inventory

Synq
Listed as “Synq ‑ TCG Pricing & Inventory”
Large singles catalogs

Imports a TCGplayer export or a CSV, makes each condition a variant with its own price, and reprices by rules that follow the TCGplayer market.

Paid plans from
$29/month
Starter, up to 2,000 cards. Free up to 100 cards; Pro $79 up to 15,000 and Scale $149 up to 50,000.
Pricing
Rules by game, set, rarity or condition, with a minimum such as your cost
At the counter
Scans singles and sealed product with Shopify POS barcodes
Trial
7 days on paid plans
TCG Cards Market Manager
Bulk imports with graded cards

Searches the card market by game, set, number, rarity or condition and bulk-imports singles, sealed product and graded cards with a variant for every condition and printing.

Paid plans from
$14.90/month
Base: 25 live-priced products and 400 imports a month. Free allows 5 imports and no live pricing; Pro $64.90 is unlimited.
Pricing
Daily price sync with your markup rules and a minimum price floor
Graded cards
Included from the Base plan
Storepass
Product creation only

Product-creation tools for stores that sell trading card games.

One plan
$99/month
Product Creation is the only plan on the listing.
Track record
Launched February 19, 2026; no reviews as of November 18, 2026

Read on the Shopify App Store on November 17 and 18, 2026, prices in USD. Each listing's plans and limits can change; tier names are the developer's, not Shopify plans.

Ask the developer one question before you install: does the app handle products with more than 100 variants? Shopify's developer changelog warns that merchants using apps not on the in-support GraphQL product APIs may have a downgraded or broken experience with products past 100 variants.

Pricing Singles Against the Market

Key takeaway

A single's price moves with the market, so it needs a reference you can check. TCGplayer publishes several price points for each card, and two of them are easy to confuse.

Market Price: This price point is compiled from recent sales completed on TCGplayer.com.
TCGplayer — What do the different price points on TCGplayer.com mean? ·

The Listed Median is a different figure: TCGplayer describes it as "the median from all listed prices for a product based on listed prices only", which is what sellers ask, not what buyers paid. Use Market Price as the reference and treat it as a guide, not a formula.

Shopify doesn't give you that reference. None of the Shopify pages we read on November 17, 2026, among them the Help Center's product, inventory, POS, sales-channel and shipping pages, shopify.com/pos and both changelog feeds, describes a built-in price guide for trading cards.

That gap is what the TCG apps fill. Synq's listing says its price rules follow the TCGplayer market on your schedule, by game, set, rarity or condition, with a minimum such as your cost; TCG Cards Market Manager lists a daily price sync with custom markup rules and a minimum price floor. Set the floor before you switch automatic pricing on, so a falling market can't reprice a card below what you paid for it.

Where to Sell Trading Cards Online: Your Store or a Marketplace?

Key takeaway

Marketplaces bring buyers who are already searching for a card. Your own store keeps the customer relationship and pays no commission, but it has to find its own traffic. Our comparison of TikTok Shop and Shopify covers who owns the customer in full; for a card seller the practical answer is often both, run from one inventory.

What Each Channel Takes From a $100 Card

Key takeaway

Each channel charges in its own way, and the differences decide where a given card belongs. The table sets the five side by side as of November 17, 2026.

Five places to sell a card, US
ChannelWhat it charges a card sellerHow it connects to ShopifyWatch for
TCGplayer Marketplace (Level 1–4)10.75% of the order subtotal, capped at $75 per product, plus 2.5% of items, shipping and tax and $0.30. A Marketplace account synced through Crystal Commerce, BinderPOS or Ion Sync pays a 9.25% commission instead, plus a sync fee set entirely by the sync providerTCGplayer connects to outside ecommerce platforms through third-party sync providersTracking above $49.99 and a signature above $250 on TCGplayer orders
eBay (US, no Store)13.25% of the sale up to $7,500 per item in the trading card categories, plus $0.30 per order up to $10 or $0.40 aboveMarketplace Connect, which syncs product and order changes automaticallyStandard Envelope only covers items under $20
WhatnotCommission on the item's sale price plus payment processing on the whole order, shipping and tax included; a new commission structure took effect September 21, 2026 for existing sellersThe Whatnot sales channel syncs products, inventory and orders, on every Shopify planLive-show purchases arrive as draft orders and become orders when the show ends
Walmart MarketplaceReferral fees in a Collectibles category open to approved sellersMarketplace Connect (Walmart US)Trading cards and comics are final sale
Your own Shopify storeShopify Payments online standard card rate in the US: 2.9% on Basic, 2.7% on Grow, 2.5% on Advanced, each plus $0.30; premium cards cost moreNativeA monthly plan (Basic is $39 a month on monthly billing in the US), and buyers you have to find yourself

TCGplayer Help Center (Fees; shipping requirements), eBay selling fees and Standard Envelope documentation, Whatnot seller fees, Walmart Marketplace Collectibles, Shopify Help Center (Marketplace Connect, Whatnot) and Shopify pricing. All read November 17, 2026.

Here is the worked example the rest of this section refers to. A $100 single sold on TCGplayer Marketplace by a Level 1–4 seller pays 10.75% commission and a 2.5% transaction fee plus $0.30, $13.55 in all; on eBay it pays 13.25% plus $0.40 per order, $13.65; in your own store on Basic, at the standard card rate, it pays 2.9% + $0.30, $3.20. Put your own card's price into the calculator below to see the same three fees.

What each channel takes from one card

In US dollars per card sold: each channel's fee on the card's price, and what is left before shipping, sales tax and your own costs.

$1–$7,500: eBay's 13.25% trading card rate holds up to $7,500 per item, so the tool stops there.

Your own store's Shopify plan

Shopify Payments, US online standard card rate: 2.9% + $0.30 (premium cards cost more). The plan's monthly price is a fixed cost, not a per-card fee.

Fee and what you keep, per card

TCGplayer Marketplace

$13.55

13.6% of the card's price

You keep $86.45

eBay, no Store

$13.65

13.7% of the card's price

You keep $86.35

Your Shopify store (Basic)

$3.20

3.2% of the card's price

You keep $96.80

Cheaper marketplace at this price

TCGplayer

$0.10 less in fees per card than eBay.

  • Above $10 and below about $698 the gap stays a flat $0.10; it widens only once TCGplayer's commission reaches its $75 cap.
  • At this price TCGplayer's commission is still under its $75 cap.
  • Your own store pays the lowest per-card fee but has to find its own buyers; the marketplaces bring them.

How the fees are counted

  • TCGplayer, Marketplace Level 1–4: 10.75% commission capped at $75 per product, plus 2.5% + $0.30.
  • eBay, US, no Store: 13.25% plus $0.30 per order up to $10, $0.40 above.
  • Card price only, US, read November 17, 2026. TCGplayer's transaction fee also counts shipping and tax, so a real order costs more there; eBay's fee page lists what its total includes.
  • Not modelled: a Marketplace account synced through a provider (9.25% commission plus the provider's sync fee), Whatnot and Walmart.

The two marketplaces sit close until TCGplayer's commission reaches its $75 cap and pull apart above it, because only TCGplayer caps its commission.

TCGplayer. Its fee page charges a Marketplace seller at Level 1 to 4 a 10.75% commission, capped at $75 per product, plus 2.5% of the order total including shipping and tax and $0.30. A Marketplace account synced through Crystal Commerce, BinderPOS or Ion Sync pays a 9.25% commission instead, plus a sync fee set entirely by the sync provider.

Cards worth $2.49 or less sold through TCGplayer Direct carry an item fee of 50% of the card's value in place of the commission, Pro, sync and transaction fees.

eBay. The 13.25% rate on eBay's selling fees page covers Sports Trading Cards, Non-Sport Trading Cards and Collectible Card Games for sellers without an eBay Store, calculated per item. The full stack on an eBay order, Store tiers and ads included, is in our guide to what an eBay order really costs.

Whatnot. Whatnot's seller fees page calculates commission on the item's sale price and payment processing on the full order, and its new commission structure took effect on September 21, 2026 for existing sellers. Shopify's Whatnot setup page adds that the fee can be lower depending on your region and the product's category, and our Whatnot guide keeps them current in its section on commission and processing fees.

Walmart. Walmart's Collectibles page opens the category to approved sellers and states that trading cards and comics remain final sale. Its referral fees are in our Walmart fee breakdown.

One Single, Five Channels: Stopping the Oversell

Key takeaway

A single is usually one card. List it on four channels with four separate stock counts and the first two buyers can both pay for it. The fix is one stock count in Shopify that every channel reads.

How each channel stays in step with Shopify stock
ChannelWhat keeps its stock in step with ShopifyThe gap to close
Online StoreShopify inventory: at zero, customers can't add the item to the cartLeave Sell when out of stock off on singles and slabs
Shopify POSSyncs orders and inventory with the admin, the online store and other active sales channelsThe continue-selling setting doesn't apply at POS; multi-location must be on
eBay, Walmart, Amazon, Target PlusMarketplace Connect syncs product and order changes automaticallyPick the quantity rule each marketplace receives
WhatnotThe Whatnot channel syncs products, inventory and ordersLive-show buys arrive as draft orders and become orders automatically when the show ends; you can also convert them by hand with Complete All Draft Orders in the Whatnot channel
TCGplayerA third-party sync provider; TCGplayer isn't among Marketplace Connect's marketplacesThe link and its fee depend on the provider you pick

Shopify Help Center (inventory tracking, Shopify POS, Marketplace Connect, Whatnot) and TCGplayer Fees, read November 17, 2026.

Marketplace Connect links Amazon, Target Plus (US), Walmart (US) and eBay, and new Etsy connections aren't available. What quantity it sends each marketplace is a setting, and our Marketplace Connect guide explains which quantity rule to pick.

The Whatnot sales channel installs from the Shopify App Store and syncs products, inventory and orders between your Shopify admin and your Whatnot account. During a live show, purchases sit as draft orders, and Shopify says all draft orders become full orders automatically when the show ends.

Pre-Orders for New Releases

Key takeaway

New sets sell before they arrive, and that is where a card shop takes its biggest promise. Two things decide whether the promise holds: the setup Shopify requires, and the date you put on the product.

What Shopify Needs Before You Take a Pre-Order

Key takeaway

Shopify lists pre-orders as one of three purchase options, beside subscriptions and try-before-you-buy. Its Pre-orders page says that "to use pre-orders, you need to install a pre-order app from the Shopify App Store and then manage pre-orders in the Shopify admin", and that pre-orders are "currently only available to merchants using Shopify Payments or Paypal Express." Its setup page adds the limits below.

Shopify's pre-order limits, read as release rules
Shopify's limitWhat it means for a release
Pre-orders run only on the Online Store and Custom Storefront sales channelsA pre-order can't be rung up on Shopify POS at your counter
Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay accelerated checkouts can't buy pre-ordersPre-order buyers pay through the standard checkout
Local payment methods such as Klarna and mollie iDEAL | Wero can't buy pre-ordersA buyer who pays that way has to choose another payment method for a pre-order
Not supported on stores with customized checkoutsCheck your checkout before you announce a release
One purchase option per product in a single checkoutA buyer can't combine a pre-order and try-before-you-buy on the same product in one checkout
Not supported by Shop PromiseShop Promise doesn't cover pre-order products
Uninstalling the app deletes its pre-order data after 48 hours, except customer payment informationExport your pre-order records before you switch apps

Shopify Help Center, Pre-orders and Setting up pre-orders, read November 17, 2026.

Once an app creates a pre-order plan, it sits on the product in a Purchase options card. The frame below shows a demo product in our test store carrying four sample plans, one of them a pre-order; it isn't one of the two apps listed after it.

In Shopify adminOpen in your store
  1. Products
  2. Purchase options
A test store's demo product shows Preorder beside three other purchase plans, each applied to one variant.

Two pre-order listings show the range of charge timing on offer, read November 18, 2026:

Two pre-order apps on the Shopify App Store

PreProduct
Listed as “PreProduct pre‑order”
Flexible charge timing

Charges upfront, later on a vaulted card, or by deposit, whichever fits your lead time.

Starter
$0
Free to install, plus 5% of paid pre-order revenue. Scale is $99.99 and Scale Plus $259.99 a month.
Trial
7 days on Scale and Scale Plus
Essent Preorder
Listed as “Essent Preorder Back in Stock”
Low-volume releases

Full or partial payment on the free plan; the listing also offers split payment and a deposit with a payment schedule, and lists mixed-cart validation on the Starter and Essentials plans.

Free plan
$0
25 pre-orders a month. Lite $4.95 (100), Starter $8.95 (300), Essentials $24.95 (500).
Trial
14 days on Lite, Starter and Essentials

Read on the Shopify App Store on November 17 and 18, 2026, prices in USD. A snapshot of two listings, not every pre-order app.

If you would rather charge only when the box ships, Shopify's API 2026-01 release candidate added an ON_FULFILLMENT trigger for the remaining balance on pre-orders. It is a tool for app developers, so check each app's listing for whether it supports charging on fulfillment.

When the Allocation Comes Up Short

Key takeaway

Allocations on new sets can arrive late or short, and that is when the rules bite. Shopify's setup page says you "must have a reasonable basis for saying that a product can be shipped within a certain time", and that with no clear date you need a reasonable belief the product ships within 30 days of purchase. That matches the US Federal Trade Commission's default for mail and internet orders:

If no time is clearly and conspicuously stated, within thirty (30) days after receipt of a properly completed order from the buyer.
US Federal Trade Commission, 16 CFR 435.2(a)(1)(ii) — Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule — eCFR ·

When a distributor cuts or delays your allocation, the steps run in this order:

1
Put a date on the product page
Shopify asks for a reasonable basis for any ship time you state. With no clear date, the 30-day default applies.
2
Send a revised date and the choice
Shopify's page says to provide a revised shipment date and explain the customer's right to cancel or get a refund. The FTC rule asks you to offer, clearly and without prior demand, consent to the delay or cancellation with a prompt refund.
3
Count on silence only within 30 days
If the revised date is 30 days or less after the original deadline, the notice must say that a buyer who doesn't reject the delay before shipment is deemed to consent. This guide covers only that case.
4
Refund within seven working days
A prompt refund is one sent by first class mail or anything as fast and reliable, within seven working days of the buyer's right to it.

Our pre-orders guide walks through the full FTC rule, longer delays included, along with the UK and EU equivalents.

How to Ship Trading Cards: Envelope, Tracked Mailer or Insured Parcel

Key takeaway

A cheap single and an expensive slab should not travel the same way. The cost of the label is small next to the cost of a lost card, so the service follows the value.

Match the Service to the Card's Value

Key takeaway

The rows below run from the cheapest way to send a card to the safest. The letter limits come from the USPS Domestic Mail Manual, the label facts from Shopify's USPS page, and the TCGplayer thresholds from its shipping requirements, which also say orders over $250.00 must ship with Signature Confirmation.

Which service for which card, US
What you are sendingServiceWhy
A low-value single in a plain envelopeUSPS First-Class Mail letterLetter size is up to 11-1/2 by 6-1/8 inches, 1/4 inch thick and 3.5 ounces; heavier pieces pay flat prices. Shopify describes its First-Class Mail labels as a way to ship large envelopes, and those labels can't be insured through Shopify, voided or refunded
An eBay sale under $20eBay Standard EnvelopeeBay limits the service to items under $20, in the US only
A thicker card mailer as a flatFirst Class Large Envelope (flat)Shopify's USPS page says tracking isn't supported for this package type
A TCGplayer order over $49.99A tracked service from a carrier integrated with TCGplayer's Seller PortalTCGplayer requires tracking on these orders and an integrated carrier to protect you against missing-order claims
A TCGplayer order over $250Signature Confirmation; Priority Mail Express includes it by defaultTCGplayer requires a signature on orders over $250
A slab worth hundreds or moreUSPS Ground Advantage or Priority Mail with Shopify insuranceUSPS includes up to $100 of coverage only with USPS Tracking; Shopify sells more, up to its own ceiling

USPS Domestic Mail Manual 101 and usps.com insurance, Shopify Help Center (USPS, shipping insurance), TCGplayer shipping requirements, eBay Standard Envelope documentation. Read November 17, 2026. TCGplayer and eBay rows apply only to orders on those marketplaces.

Two more lines for TCGplayer sellers: its shipping requirements tell you to use a carrier integrated with the Seller Portal to protect yourself against missing-order claims, and its Safeguard coverage for untracked orders applies only to orders of $49.99 and under placed on or after August 17, 2026, and only for sellers based in the US or US territories with 1,000 lifetime orders. A new store doesn't qualify. eBay's Standard Envelope is limited to items under $20 and isn't available in every card category.

In your own store, save the mailer you use most as a package in Settings › Shipping and delivery › Packages and make it the store default. The page itself puts the reason plainly: set package sizes to get accurate shipping rates.

In Shopify adminOpen in your store
  1. Settings
  2. Shipping and delivery
  3. Packages
A saved envelope set as the store default; Add package creates the next mailer size.

Packing the card is the part the rules above don't cover. TRIKE Sports Cards, a card seller's YouTube channel, shows the packing method it uses for sports cards in a 2023 video. It reflects one seller's practice, and any prices or services in it predate the figures in this section.

How To Ship Sports Cards! (Cheapest & Easiest Method)TRIKE Sports Cards shows its own method for packing and shipping sports cards. One practitioner's practice, 2023.

Insurance and Claims on Shopify Labels

Key takeaway

If you ship from the United States and buy labels in Shopify, Shopify's insurance page lets you buy coverage up to $5,000 per shipment, in $100 increments, at $0.89 per $100 of domestic coverage. With Shopify Payments on the Grow, Advanced or Plus plan, up to $200 of insurance is included on each eligible label at no extra cost. What the extra coverage costs on a given card, and when it pays, is in our guide to the insurance line on a label.

Two limits shape a card shop's choices. USPS First Class Mail isn't eligible for this insurance. And the claim is Shipsurance's, not Shopify's: you submit it from the order in your Shopify admin, Shipsurance administers it, Shopify's Help Center sends questions about it to Shipsurance support, and for most shipments the window runs from 24 hours after the order has shipped to 120 days from the shipping date.

USPS's own insurance page adds that Ground Advantage includes up to $100 of coverage only with a USPS Tracking barcode, and that extra USPS insurance runs up to $5,000.

Read the insurer's terms before a valuable card ships

Shipsurance's terms for Shopify shipments, in an archived copy dated July 30, 2026, set conditions a card seller can trip over. Confirm them with Shipsurance before you rely on them, because they may have changed.

  • Invoice. Insured shipments must be under a commercial sales invoice to be covered.
  • Labelling. Loss is excluded when a label or packaging describes or alludes to the contents, and the terms say this includes the manufacturer packaging.
  • Signature. A parcel that required a signature service but was sent without one is excluded.
  • Named categories. Jewelry worth $1,000 or more must ship with signature confirmation; cards aren't named in that list, which doesn't mean they are covered without one.

Jewelry stores face the same insurer terms on high-value parcels, and our jewelry store guide's insured shipping section compares the routes for parcels worth more than the included cover.

Payment Rules That Touch a Card Shop

Key takeaway

Card shops sit close to two lines payment providers watch: fakes and prizes. Shopify's Shopify Payments eligibility page names both, and the rest comes from Stripe's list, which Shopify's US Payments terms point to through the processor list.

Rules a card shop runs into
RuleWhose ruleWhat it means for a card shop
Counterfeit products: products or services that infringe intellectual property rightsShopify Payments; Stripe lists counterfeit goods tooOnly authentic cards can go through Shopify Payments
Gambling products and services, "such as sports forecasting, lotteries, bidding, contests, or sweepstakes"Shopify PaymentsRead any prize or chance-based offer against this category before you sell it
Games of skill, card games included, "with a monetary or material prize"Stripe, one of Shopify Payments' two US processorsPrize-paying card tournaments sit in the gambling group of Stripe's prohibited businesses
"Payments of an entry or player fee that promise the entrant or player will win a prize of value"StripeTournament entry sold with a guaranteed prize is on the same prohibited list

Shopify Help Center, Shopify Payments eligibility; Stripe prohibited and restricted businesses list. Read November 17, 2026. Not legal advice.

Shopify's US Payments terms say the prohibited and restricted categories are provided by each payment processor. Shopify's processor list names Stripe, Inc. and PayPal, Inc. for Shopify Payments in the US, and Stripe's list of prohibited businesses includes card games with a monetary or material prize and entry fees that promise a prize of value. Shopify also says its list of prohibited products "isn't exhaustive and it varies depending on your region."

Above both sits Shopify's Acceptable Use Policy: "You can't use Shopify to do anything that's illegal where you do business." The same policy notes that most product eligibility or takedown disputes come from outside Shopify, from regulators and third-party IP rights holders. We don't draw legal conclusions here; if an offer sits near one of these lines, ask Shopify Support before you sell it.

Running a Counter Alongside the Online Store

Key takeaway

Shopify's POS page says Shopify POS "syncs with your Shopify admin to track orders and inventory across your retail locations, online store, and other active sales channels." For a card shop that is the main reason to run the counter on POS: one stock count for the counter and the site.

Two settings come first. To use Shopify POS, multi-location must be activated in your store settings. And the continue-selling setting doesn't apply to POS, as the slab section above explains, so one-of-a-kind cards need a stock check before a counter sale.

If you stock many singles, Synq's listing says it scans singles and sealed product at the counter with Shopify POS barcodes. Events bring in the manufacturer programs: WPN's play-space condition is in the sourcing section above, and prize tournaments meet Stripe's list of prohibited businesses. Our POS app guide covers how the app syncs with your online store in daily use.

Trading Card Store Launch Checklist

Key takeaway

Steps one to three apply to every store. Singles stores spend most of their time on steps four to six, sealed-first stores on step seven, counter stores on step six, and slab stores on step eight. Do step three before any import: a theme or app that stops at 100 variants is cheaper to find before the first large product is built.

Trading card store launch checklistTick each step off as you go from product mix to first shipped order.

Trading card store launch checklist

Tick each step off as you go from product mix to first shipped order.

0 of 8 done
  1. Decide how much sealed product, singles and graded slabs you will carry, and whether a manufacturer program is open to your store.

  2. Use one product per single with Condition as an option, and one product per slab with a quantity of one.

  3. Confirm the theme, apps and sales channels handle products with more than 100 variants before a large import.

  4. Bring singles in by CSV or a TCGplayer export, through an app if hand entry won't keep up.

  5. Price from TCGplayer's Market Price and set a minimum so automatic repricing can't go below your cost.

  6. Run every marketplace from the same Shopify stock so a single that sells anywhere drops to zero everywhere.

  7. Install a pre-order app, state a ship date on each release, and write down how you will handle a delay.

  8. Save your mailer as a package and decide which cards go as letters, tracked parcels or insured parcels with a signature.

The Bottom Line

Key takeaway

Shopify supplies the catalog, inventory, pre-order framework and labels; the card-specific parts, market pricing and TCGplayer sync, come from apps and providers you choose.

Build the inventory before the storefront. Whatever your route, build one stock count first: condition variants on singles, quantity one on slabs, every channel on the same inventory. A card sold twice costs more goodwill than any design choice wins back.
Your Next Step by Stage
Setting up the catalogFor stores entering singles: variant limits, CSV imports and what to do when native variants aren't enough.Shopify product variants
Planning a releaseFor sealed-product sellers: gateways, deposits, charge timing and ship-date rules in the US, UK and EU.Shopify pre-orders
If you want the store builtHave the storefront built on a theme from $650, while channel sync and card apps stay in your hands.See store creation

Try the Card Catalog Setup on a Trial

As of November 2026, Shopify gives new stores a free 3-day trial, then $1 a month on most plans for the first 3 months in the US. That is enough to add a single with its Condition variants, a slab at quantity one and a test order before you pay for any card app.

Start Free Trial

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. Shopify's product taxonomy has a Gaming Cards category under Collectible Trading Cards with a Condition attribute, so singles, sealed product and graded slabs all fit its catalog. Shopify Payments refuses counterfeit products, so sell only authentic cards, and read its gambling category before offering anything prize-based. Its list of prohibited products isn't exhaustive and varies by region.
Add Condition as an option on each single, so every condition becomes a variant with its own price and stock. Shopify's product taxonomy gives Condition 16 default values such as Near mint (NM); Lightly, Moderately and Heavily Played are not among them. Category metafields have default entries you can customize, so add those grades with Add new entry.
Up to 2,048 variants and 3 options per product, so condition, printing and language fit as three options. Shopify warns that some third-party themes, theme app extensions, public apps and sales channels might not support more than 100 variants, so test your theme and channel apps before importing large single listings.
On a $100 card the fees are close: $13.55 for a TCGplayer Marketplace seller at Level 1–4 and $13.65 on eBay without a Store, before shipping and tax. TCGplayer's commission stops at $75 per product, while eBay's 13.25% keeps rising up to $7,500, so the gap widens on expensive cards. Shopify Payments on Basic, at the standard card rate, takes $3.20.
Not through Marketplace Connect, which links Amazon, eBay and, in the US, Target Plus and Walmart. TCGplayer connects to outside ecommerce platforms through third-party sync providers, and its fee page names Crystal Commerce, BinderPOS and Ion Sync as examples. Those providers set their own sync fee, and a synced account pays a 9.25% commission instead of 10.75%. Whatnot connects through its own Shopify sales channel.
No. Shopify's Help Center says you need to install a pre-order app from the Shopify App Store and then manage pre-orders in the admin. It also says pre-orders are currently only available with Shopify Payments or PayPal Express. Pre-orders run only on the Online Store and custom storefronts, not Shopify POS, and Shop Pay, Apple Pay or Google Pay can't buy them.
State a ship date and keep it. Without a clear date, the US FTC rule and Shopify's own page give 30 days. For US buyers, if a release slips, you must offer a choice between accepting the delay and cancelling for a prompt refund, sent within seven working days. Silence counts as consent only when the new date is 30 days late or less.
A USPS First-Class Mail letter, if the envelope stays within 11-1/2 by 6-1/8 inches, 1/4 inch thick and 3.5 ounces. Shopify describes its First-Class Mail labels as a way to ship large envelopes; they can't be insured through Shopify or voided, and the First Class Large Envelope (flat) supports no tracking on a Shopify label. Use the letter for low-value cards.
TCGplayer requires Signature Confirmation on its orders over $250 and tracking on orders over $49.99. In your own store the threshold is your decision. On a Shopify label, Priority Mail Express includes Signature Confirmation by default, and an insurer may exclude a parcel that required a signature but was sent without one.
On Shopify labels for shipments from the US, yes: up to $5,000 per shipment, in $100 steps. Grow, Advanced and Plus stores with Shopify Payments get up to $200 included on eligible labels. USPS First Class Mail isn't eligible. You submit claims from the order in your Shopify admin; Shipsurance administers them, for most shipments 24 hours to 120 days after shipping.
Not on the terms Wizards publishes for the US and Canada. Among other conditions, its application guide asks for a store that is already open for business, doesn't share space with or sit inside another business, and has a dedicated play space with seating for eight or more players. Elsewhere, stores should follow the same guide unless their regional WPN team directs otherwise.
Check first. Shopify's processor list names Stripe, Inc. and PayPal, Inc. for Shopify Payments in the US, and Stripe's list of prohibited businesses includes card games with a monetary or material prize and entry fees that promise a prize of value. Shopify's own gambling category names lotteries, bidding, contests and sweepstakes, and its list isn't exhaustive.
About This Article
Shopify Developer & Editorial Director
9+ years with Shopify since 2017

Front-end developer specializing in Shopify since 2017. Experienced in building custom Liquid themes, optimizing storefront performance, and integrating third-party apps. Directs the editorial process behind Ecom Store Pro: sets its topics and the rules every AI-written page must pass before publication.

This page was written by AI. Separate AI agents that did not write it check its figures and claims against official sources and test its links and interactive tools. A human editor sets the site's editorial direction, topics and rules and checks that pages are complete and display correctly, but does not check their facts or edit their text. Details may change — always confirm critical data at shopify.com.

Editorial Policy

Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you sign up for a Shopify store through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our full advertising policy.

Continue Learning

What to Read Next

Stay updated

Get notified about new articles

Subscribe to receive updates when we publish new Shopify guides and insights.