The short version
Insider Club puts a customer forum on a page of your Shopify store, where customers join with their store customer account, or one Shopify creates when they first sign in, and its Free plan has unlimited members and posts with first-post approval, reports and bans.
Growth adds photos, polls, a password-protected forum and staff moderators for $19.99 a month in US dollars as of November 16, 2026.
As of November 16, 2026, the App Store listing also shows a Pro plan with AI moderation that the developer's pricing page doesn't list, so buy Pro for AI moderation only if your own plan screen offers it.
Install Insider Club if customers already ask each other about your products and someone can check the moderation queue daily, knowing that it doesn't charge for access itself: its developer says a paid club needs a subscription app alongside it.
A forum on a page of your Shopify store, where customers sign in with their store customer account and you moderate posts; members and posts are unlimited on Free.
- Free
- $0
- Unlimited members, admins and posts · sign-in with the store customer account
- no time limit, November 16, 2026
- Growth
- $19.99/month
- Photos, polls, a password-protected forum, roles, staff moderators
- or $199/year; 14-day free trial, November 16, 2026
- Pro
- $29.99/month
- AI moderation, daily email summary, advanced design
- or $299/year; not on the developer's pricing page, November 16, 2026
- Priced by:
- Features — not members or posts
- — USD, billed through Shopify
- Reviews
- 2
- as of November 16, 2026
- Rating
- 5.0
- as of November 16, 2026
- Launched
- October 22, 2026
Should You Install Insider Club?
Find your situation in column one; the sections below show what each answer rests on.
Should you install Insider Club, by store situation
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Customers ask each other about your products, and someone can check a moderation queue daily | Install it on Free | Free covers the forum page, sign-in with the store customer account, first-post approval, reports and bans, with no cap on members or posts |
| Members need to post photos, run polls, or keep the forum behind a password | Growth, $19.99 a month in USD | The App Store listing and the developer's pricing page both put these on Growth, as of November 16, 2026 |
| You want AI to screen posts before they go live | Only if your own plan screen offers Pro | AI moderation sits on Pro in the App Store listing, but the developer's pricing page showed only Free and Growth on November 16, 2026 |
| You want to charge customers for access to the forum | Not on its own | Insider Club doesn't take payment for forum access itself; the developer's blog post on forum apps says a paid club needs a subscription app alongside it, as of November 17, 2026 |
| Your customer base is small and nobody has time to moderate | Wait | Insider Club's terms make you responsible for moderating your forum diligently |
What Insider Club Does on Your Store, and Where It Stops
Key takeaway
Insider Club is a forum app by The Modern Apps that adds a community to your store through the theme editor: an app block called Forum goes on a page template, the developer's install guide says, and the forum then lives at that page's address, for example yourstore.com/pages/community, according to its help. Customers don't create a separate account: its pricing page says a logged-in customer is automatically a member.
What you get with Insider Club, by plan
| What you get | Plan | Where it stops |
|---|---|---|
| A forum on a page of your store, inside your theme's header and menu | Free | Needs an Online Store 2.0 theme with app blocks; the app's help names Dawn and Horizon |
| Sign-in with the store customer account, or one Shopify creates when a shopper first signs in | Free | Works only while sign-in links for customer accounts are turned on in your Shopify settings |
| First-post approval, member reports and bans | Free | You or your team do the moderating; staff moderators are a Growth feature |
| Blocked words and daily posting limits | No plan named on the listing; Growth on the pricing page | What Free showed in practice: see our test |
| A Latest posts block for any page, forum statistics and email alerts | Free | A daily email summary is listed on Pro only |
| Forum interface in English, French, Spanish or German | Free | What the language setting changed: see our test |
| Photos and video links in posts, polls and subcategories, @mentions | Growth | Not on Free |
| A password-protected forum, roles, badges, private categories and staff moderators | Growth | On Free, the forum is either public or open to any logged-in customer |
| AI moderation of posts and replies, a daily email summary, advanced design, scheduled Team posts | Pro | Not on the developer's pricing page, which showed no Pro plan on November 16, 2026 |
Source: the App Store listing and the developer's pricing page, both read November 16, 2026, plus the app's own help for theme support. These are the developer's descriptions of its plans.
It fits less well in five cases:
- You want to sell access to a community. Insider Club doesn't take payment for forum access itself; the developer's blog post on forum apps says a paid club needs a subscription app alongside it, and the same post recommends Mega Community for selling access to a community (read November 17, 2026).
- You want points or rewards for activity built in. No Insider Club page we read on November 17, 2026 describes a built-in points or rewards system; the closest are roles and badges on Growth.
- You want a long track record. The listing launched on October 22, 2026 and showed a 5.0 rating from 2 reviews as of November 16, 2026.
- You only need replies under blog posts or one-to-one chat. Shopify's built-in tools may do: blog comments can be held for approval but give you no reply action, as our guide on whether to turn on blog comments explains, and Shopify Inbox handles one-to-one chat rather than a place where customers answer each other.
- Nobody can moderate. Insider Club's terms say you are solely responsible for your store, your members and the content on your forum, and ask you to moderate diligently: handle reports, promptly remove content that is unlawful or breaks your rules and answer members' data requests. Shopify's own blog makes a similar point for B2B businesses:
If your customer base is very small, your product is highly specialized, or your team is stretched thin, direct one-on-one relationships may serve you better.
Three Stores Where Insider Club Pays Off
Key takeaway
The three situations below are where Insider Club's forum page on your store, with sign-in through the store customer account, or one Shopify creates when a customer first signs in, does work that blog comments, reviews and chat don't. Each says what to switch on, what to pair Insider Club with, and where it stops.
Customers keep asking the same product questions
Key takeaway
This is the store whose products come with a learning curve: hobby kits, outdoor gear, a skincare routine. Insider Club gives these customers a place on your own store to ask questions and swap advice, set up in three moves:
- Keep the categories the app suggests during setup, Announcements for your team, Questions, Product reviews and Help, and rename them in your customers' words.
- Add the app's second block, Latest posts, to your home page or another busy page from the Apps tab in the theme editor, so shoppers see recent discussions where they browse.
- Turn on approval of a new member's first post, so spam never reaches the page unseen.
- Online Store
- Themes
- Edit theme
Pair it with a reviews app rather than replacing one: a review rates the product on its page, while a forum thread answers a question. Our guide to Shopify product reviews covers that side, and questions about a specific order still belong in one-to-one chat.
Where it stops: the listing puts photos in posts on Growth, and product cards appear only in your team's posts, also on Growth. Links that members write stay off by default to limit spam, the developer's help says, until you allow them for everyone. How posting worked for a member on Free is in our test.
A members-only space for your repeat buyers
Key takeaway
Some stores have a core of repeat buyers worth a space of their own: early news, product feedback, a direct line to the team. Insider Club's Settings screen decides who can read the forum. On Free it offers Public or Logged-in customers only, and the option to add a password is locked to Growth.
The developer's help FAQ says anonymous posting can be turned on in the settings and is off by default; what the app's Settings screen said about it is in our test.
- Apps
- Insider Club
- Settings
Logged in is not the same as bought. Shopify's customer accounts help says that when someone signs in with an email not tied to an existing customer profile, a new profile is created automatically. Our guide to locking a page explains why a buyers-only check needs a tag, not just a sign-in.
On Growth, you can protect the whole forum with a password, the developer's first-settings guide says, and the listing adds roles, badges and private categories. For a space reserved for buyers of specific products, Social Place's listing describes exactly that. To charge for membership, the developer's own blog says a paid club needs a subscription app alongside Insider Club, and it recommends Mega Community for selling access to a community.
Public answers that Google can find
Key takeaway
The developer pitches Insider Club partly on search: its home page says your customers' questions become pages on your store that Google indexes. That is marketing, not a promise. Its privacy policy is more careful: topics and replies in public categories are visible to every visitor and may be indexed by search engines, together with the author's display name, while categories reserved for logged-in customers are not accessible to search engines.
The follow-up is yours. Insider Club's terms state: “It is your responsibility to inform your Members of this and to choose the categories concerned.”
Put that line into the community rules members accept, alongside the privacy policy's note that the forum is for people aged 15 or over. Then three settings:
- Decide in the app's Settings whether the forum is public or for logged-in customers only.
- Decide whether the box that allows Google to index discussions should be ticked, in the same Settings; what it was set to by default is in our test.
- Choose a fixed forum language if it should differ from your store's: the interface comes in English, French, Spanish or German, so write category names and pinned posts in the same language.
- Apps
- Insider Club
- Settings
- Apps
- Insider Club
- Settings
Treat search traffic as a bonus rather than the reason to install: whether a given discussion is indexed is the search engine's call, which is why the privacy policy says “may”.
Our Test: Insider Club on the Free Plan
Key takeaway
We tested Insider Club ourselves on November 13, 2026, on the Free plan, in our own Shopify development store running the Dawn theme. We installed it ourselves; the developer gave us no access or payment, and we didn't ask for a link. Twelve results change what you should do:
Insider Club on the Free plan, November 13, 2026
| What we checked | What happened | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Installing on Free | No plan screen appeared: the app opened on Free, and its home page and Settings showed Plan · Free, billed by Shopify | You can try it without picking a paid plan |
| Access it asked for | Store owner contact data, Online Store pages on a path the app controls, files, and locale and Markets settings; no customer or order data. Setup later asked for theme and Online Store pages access | Expect a second access prompt during setup if the install screen doesn't already list theme access |
| Setup | About 32 minutes from install to the published welcome post, with a screenshot of every step; two jobs happened outside the app: the theme template with its block, and the menu item. The app's Check my setup did not detect our menu item | Budget under an hour, and tick the menu step yourself if the check misses it |
| Customer sign-in | Log in on the forum led to the store's customer-account sign-in; the emailed code arrived in under a minute; there was no separate forum password | Members join with their store customer account; on their first post they set a public name and nickname, and the last name shows as an initial |
| Posting as a member | Text with bold, lists and emoji; no link or photo buttons; replies were flat; the settings say a link a member writes shows as plain text | Photo posts and threaded replies are Growth features in the app's plan comparison, so plan for text-only posts on Free |
| Moderation | First-post approval held the new member's post until we approved it, and the same member's reply then went live at once. A report didn't hide the post. Review and report emails each arrived within about a minute. Blocked words (up to 50) and daily limits (5 posts and 30 replies by default) were available on Free | Free covers approvals, reports, bans and word filters; check the limits in your own admin before you rely on them |
| Notification settings | Alerts for reported posts and for posts waiting for review were on by default, alerts for new posts off; with Send to left empty, alerts go to the store's email, up to 20 emails a day per store | Set Send to an address someone checks daily |
| Forum language | Switching to French translated buttons and labels; post titles, texts and category names stayed as written. The app's admin stays in English | Write category names and pinned posts in your customers' language yourself |
| Search indexing | Allow Google to index discussions was on by default, and a post page had its own title, canonical URL and description | Untick it before launch if your forum should stay out of search |
| Latest posts block | Added to the home page from the theme editor's Apps tab, it showed three discussions by default, as cards or a compact list, with a View all link | Use it to lead shoppers from a busy page into the forum |
| Plans inside the app | The app's plan comparison showed three plans, Free, Growth and Pro, with AI moderation, a daily email summary and advanced design on Pro, billed by Shopify on the Shopify invoice | Check your own plan screen before you pay for Pro |
| Members and data | The Members page listed each member's posts, replies and likes, with Export CSV and a View customer in Shopify link; a data access log recorded views, exports and moderation actions | You can export the member list yourself; ask the developer for a copy of the discussions before you uninstall |
Source: our development store, one tester, November 13, 2026. Timings include taking screenshots and come from a single run.
On four points, what we saw differed from what the developer's own pages say. The rest of this article gives the developer's words; our results stand here beside them, and our test ran on a development store.
Where our test differed from the developer's pages, November 13, 2026
| What the developer's pages say | What our test showed | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Plans: the developer's pricing page shows only Free and Growth, as of November 16, 2026 | The app's plan comparison showed three plans, with AI moderation on Pro | Check your own plan screen before you pay for Pro |
| Anonymous posting: the developer's help FAQ says it can be turned on in the settings and is off by default, as read November 17, 2026 | The app's Settings screen said that posting always requires a customer account | Look for the anonymous option in your own Settings before you tell members they can post without an account |
| Blocked words and daily posting limits: the developer's pricing page lists them under Growth, and the App Store listing names no plan for them, as of November 16, 2026 | Blocked words (up to 50) and daily limits (5 posts and 30 replies by default) were available on Free | If the limits matter to you, check which plan your own admin puts them on before you choose between Free and Growth |
| Access at install: the developer's install guide says Shopify asks you to confirm access to “customers, online store”, as read November 16, 2026 | The Install app screen listed no customer or order data | Read the Install app screen yourself before you approve it |
Sources: the developer's help FAQ, pricing page, App Store listing and install guide, read November 16 and 17, 2026; our development store on the Free plan, one tester, November 13, 2026.
We didn't test the Growth or Pro plans, AI moderation, the Horizon theme, or uninstalling the app; it is still installed on that store, and we opened the Ban member dialog without banning anyone.
Which Plan: Free, Growth or Pro?
Key takeaway
Which Insider Club plan, by what you need
| If you need | Plan | Price, USD, as of November 16, 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| A forum page, sign-in with customer accounts, approvals, reports, bans, statistics and email alerts | Free | $0, no time limit |
| Photos and video links, polls, a password, roles and badges, private categories or staff moderators | Growth | $19.99 a month or $199 a year |
| AI moderation of posts and replies, a daily email summary or advanced design | Pro (not on the developer's pricing page) | $29.99 a month or $299 a year |
Source: the App Store listing and the developer's pricing page, read November 16, 2026; the pricing page shows no Pro plan. Billed by Shopify in US dollars.
Prices are in US dollars and billed through Shopify with your other apps, according to the developer's pricing page, which lists Growth at $19.99 a month or $199 a year on November 16, 2026. The Free plan can be used with no time limit, its terms say.
The two pages disagree on Pro. As of November 16, 2026, the App Store listing shows three plans, with AI moderation of posts and replies on Pro at $29.99 a month or $299 a year, while the developer's pricing page shows only Free and Growth, and the terms name both pages as the source of plans. What the plan screen inside the app showed is in our test.
Until the developer settles it, build your moderation on the Free and Growth features both pages list, and don't pay for Pro expecting AI moderation until your own plan screen offers it.
The listing, the pricing page and the terms state a 14-day free trial as of November 16, 2026, the listing on Growth and Pro and the pricing page on Growth, and the developer confirmed the 14 days to us by email on November 17, 2026. Only one trial is granted per store, the terms say, so start it when you can test the paid features you need within those 14 days.
You change plan on the app's Subscription page and cancel by uninstalling the app from Apps in Shopify, the developer's plan guide says. If you return to Free before a trial ends, the forum stays on Free and published posts are kept for as long as the app stays installed, its terms say.
What to Set Up Before You Invite Customers
Key takeaway
Setup runs across three places: your store's settings, the theme editor and Insider Club's own admin. Do it in this order.
Tick the steps off as you go. Steps one to five are explained below with the screen each happens on, step six in the two scenarios above, and step seven at the end of this section.
Before You Invite Customers to Your Insider Club ForumSeven steps across your Shopify settings, the theme editor and Insider Club's admin. Your progress is saved in this browser.
Before You Invite Customers to Your Insider Club Forum
Seven steps across your Shopify settings, the theme editor and Insider Club's admin. Your progress is saved in this browser.
Confirm that Show sign-in links is on in Settings > Customer accounts, because members sign in to the forum with their store customer account.
Before you tick this off
- Show sign-in links is on in Settings > Customer accounts
- A test customer can sign in with the emailed code
Read the Install app screen and the developer's privacy policy before you confirm the install.
Before you tick this off
- Read the data and store areas listed on the Install app screen
- Opened the developer's privacy policy from that screen
- Noted any extra access the app asks for during setup
Create a community page template in the theme editor and add Insider Club's Forum block from the Apps tab.
Before you tick this off
- Template named community, based on Default page
- Forum block added from the Apps tab and saved
Create the Community page with the app's button, then add it to your main menu in Content > Menus.
Before you tick this off
- The Community page uses the community template
- Your main menu has a Community item
- The page opens inside your store's header and menu
Choose whether posts publish immediately or wait for review and whether a new member's first post or reply waits for approval, decide on member links, and send alerts to an address someone reads daily.
Before you tick this off
- Publish immediately or review before publishing chosen
- First post or reply approval ticked or left unticked by choice
- Member links allowed or left off by choice
- Alert email address set
Choose Public or Logged-in customers only, decide on the search indexing box, and tell members in the community rules that public posts may be indexed.
Before you tick this off
- Access option chosen in the app's Settings
- Search indexing box ticked or unticked by choice
- Community rules mention that public posts may appear in search
Ask the developer how to get a copy of your discussions, so you can request it before you ever uninstall the app.
Before you tick this off
- You know how to request a copy of the discussions
- You know the Community page and menu item stay after an uninstall
Make sure customers can sign in. Insider Club signs members in with your store's customer accounts, and its help says that if the forum's sign-in buttons don't respond, you check that customer accounts are enabled in Settings > Customer accounts. There, Show sign-in links must be on.
- Settings
- Customer accounts
Shopify's help is plain about what happens otherwise:
After you hide sign-in links, customers can't sign in, and your customer accounts menu no longer displays on your store.
If your store is still on legacy customer accounts, Shopify deprecated them in February 2026: they are no longer available to new stores or to stores not already using them, and the final sunset date was still to be announced as of November 16, 2026. Our guide to the customer accounts migration covers the move.
Read the access screen as you install. On the listing, click Install, and Shopify shows an Install app screen with the data and areas of your store the app needs, plus a link to the developer's privacy policy. The listing's data-access block, as of November 17, 2026, names store owner contact data, products and collections, Online Store page content on a path the app controls, the theme and Online Store pages, files, and locale and Markets settings, with no customer data.
The developer's install guide, though, says Shopify asks you to confirm access to “customers, online store”, so read the screen yourself before you approve it. What the app asked for during our setup is in our test.
- Settings
- Apps
Put the Forum block on a community page. Themes don't include app blocks after an app is installed, Shopify's developer documentation notes, so you add Insider Club's yourself. In Online Store > Themes, click Edit theme, create a page template named community based on Default page, then click Add section, open the Apps tab, add the Forum block and save. In Dawn, the theme editor offered Hide but no Remove for the new template's Page section on November 13, 2026.
- Online Store
- Themes
- Edit theme
- Online Store
- Themes
- Edit theme
Shopify's theme help adds that app blocks work only with compatible themes and that some sections don't accept them, which is why a dedicated template is the safe route.
Create the page and link it in your menu. The app's setup checklist creates the Community page with its own button. The menu link is yours to add: in Content > Menus, open your main menu, click Add menu item, link it to the Community page and save.
- Apps
- Insider Club
- Home
- Content
- Menus
Set moderation before the first invitation. In the app's Settings, choose whether posts publish immediately or wait for review, and whether a new member's first post or reply waits for approval. Decide too whether members may add links, which are off by default. Then send the app's email alerts to an address someone on your team reads daily.
The developer's moderation guide describes the rest: messages with blocked words are held for review, any member can report a message and you get an email, and you can warn, suspend or ban a member.
- Apps
- Insider Club
- Settings
After launch, the Moderation page is the daily check:
- Apps
- Insider Club
- Moderation
If you remove the app later
Key takeaway
Removing a forum app is the one step you can't fully take back, so know the sequence before you need it:
- Billing. The subscription ends when you uninstall and the period already billed remains due, Insider Club's terms say; Shopify's uninstall help adds that you might still be billed for the current cycle.
- Your theme. Blocks from an app's theme extension are removed from your themes automatically on uninstall, but the app's help says the Community page and its menu item stay, so delete them yourself.
- The data. Shopify sends the app a request to erase your store's data 48 hours after you uninstall; the developer's privacy policy says it then deletes the store's and members' data no later than 30 days after uninstallation, and purges backups within the following 30 days. The app's help says reinstalling within 48 hours brings the discussions back.
- Before you uninstall. Ask the developer for a copy of all your forum's discussions, which its privacy policy says you can request at any time and its terms say you can request until uninstallation.
The Bottom Line
Key takeaway
Insider Club does one job well for a Shopify store: it gives customers a place on your own domain to answer each other, signed in with their store customer account or one Shopify creates when they first sign in, and Free covers the moderation a small team needs to start.
Frequently Asked Questions
Front-end developer specializing in Shopify since 2017. Experienced in building custom Liquid themes, optimizing storefront performance, and integrating third-party apps. Directs the editorial process behind Ecom Store Pro: sets its topics and the rules every AI-written page must pass before publication.
This page was written by AI. Separate AI agents that did not write it check its figures and claims against official sources and test its links and interactive tools. A human editor sets the site's editorial direction, topics and rules and checks that pages are complete and display correctly, but does not check their facts or edit their text. Details may change — always confirm critical data at shopify.com.
Editorial PolicySome links in this article are affiliate links. If you sign up for a Shopify store through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our full advertising policy.
